Best American Standard Faucet Handles

TL;DR: At $18.62, the American Standard Colony lever handle delivers a polished‑chrome, ABS‑plastic replacement for Colony series showers, weighing just 295 g, but its 3.7‑star rating reflects mixed user feedback.

The handle measures 108 mm in length, 63.5 mm in width, and a virtually flat 0.1 mm height, giving it a sleek profile that sits comfortably on the faucet. Weighing 295 g, it’s light enough for quick swaps, and its polished chrome finish is listed as corrosion‑resistant. The ABS plastic construction keeps the cost low while meeting ADA‑compliant lever requirements.

Compared with the seven other handles in this roundup, its 4.25‑in length is a touch longer than the Hansengroyi handle’s 4.2‑in length yet shorter than the American Standard Lever Handle’s 4.6‑in length. It also sits on the budget‑friendly side of the group, making it more affordable than the Gcbcrit option. However, its 3.7‑star rating sits below several higher‑rated alternatives, indicating that some users find it less satisfying than competitors.

Reviewers consistently praise the precise OEM fit for American Standard Colony faucets and the durable chrome finish that resists tarnish. Professional reviewers note the lightweight design and easy‑to‑operate lever as strong points. The most common complaint is the missing set screw, which forces a separate purchase, and some users feel the ABS material feels less premium than all‑metal handles.

Technical details round out the picture: the handle is a replacement‑type lever, compatible exclusively with the American Standard Colony series, and comes with a one‑year limited warranty. No additional accessories are included, so you’ll need to source the set screw yourself if it isn’t already on hand.

Best for: Entry-level buyers or those on a tight budget — the American Standard Colony Handle offers Packaging Height: 68.6 mm

Avoid if: You need a handle for a new faucet installation or a non‑Colony brand faucet

TL;DR: The Danco American Standard Handle pair offers a chrome‑finished, zinc lever design that fits Cadet faucets, measures a tall 5.13 in height, and costs just $12.78, though its 3.2‑star rating hints at mixed reviews.

The most eye‑catching dimension is the 5.13 in handle height, which is substantially taller than the typical 2.0‑in to 2.8‑in heights seen on rivals. At a light 0.15 lb, the handles feel sturdy without adding bulk, and the 3.74 in handle length gives plenty of leverage for everyday use.

Compared with the seven other handles in this roundup, Danco’s width of 4.13 in exceeds BrassCraft’s 4.0 in and dwarfs the 2.0‑in widths of Insihay, Hansengroyi and Gcbcrit. Its 5.0 in overall length matches Insihay’s but outstretches BrassCraft’s 4.25 in and the 4.2‑in lengths of Hansengroyi and Gcbcrit. In weight, Danco sits between the very light 0.01 lb American Standard Lever and the heavier 0.3 lb BrassCraft, making it easier to handle than the bulkier BrassCraft while still feeling more solid than the feather‑light alternative.

Professional reviewers note the handles are “specifically engineered” for American Standard Cadet two‑handle lavatory faucets, and the zinc construction is praised for durability. However, the 3.2‑star average rating from 75 reviews suggests some owners have run into issues, and the limited compatibility means they won’t work on single‑handle or non‑Cadet models.

Installation is DIY‑friendly: a Phillips screwdriver is all you need, and the chrome‑plated finish blends with most bathroom decors. Each package includes two lever handles made from zinc, designed to replace the original Cadet components without professional help.

Best for: Shoppers on a tight budget who want the most for their money — the Danco American Standard Handle offers Handle Length: 3.74 in

Avoid if: Reliability and user satisfaction are your top concerns

TL;DR: The Gcbcrit Shower Handle delivers precise temperature control with a sturdy zinc‑alloy lever, fits American Standard 1674 series faucets, and installs easily for $24.99.

What really sets this handle apart is its single‑lever pressure‑balance valve, which lets you fine‑tune water temperature in one smooth motion. The lever measures 2.0 inches in height and width, and stretches 4.2 inches long, giving you a comfortable grip without crowding the faucet plate.

Compared with the six other handles in this roundup, the Gcbcrit sits at the higher end of the price spectrum but offers a polished‑chrome finish and zinc‑alloy construction that feel more premium than the nickel‑brushed Insihay or the brass‑based BrassCraft options. Its 4.2‑inch length is shorter than Insihay’s 5.0‑inch lever, yet longer than the Danco handle’s 3.74 inch length, striking a balance between reach and compactness. While the American Standard Lever Handle lists a 1.90‑inch height, the Gcbcrit’s 2.0‑inch profile gives a slightly more substantial feel without sacrificing style.

Users who have installed the Gcbcrit note that all necessary components come in the box, making a DIY install straightforward; a few also mention that professional help is welcome if you prefer. Reviewers consistently highlight the precise temperature control as a major plus, though a handful point out that the Gcbcrit brand isn’t as widely recognized as American Standard, which can be a concern for brand‑loyal buyers.

Compatibility is clear‑cut: the handle is designed for the American Standard 1674 series, specifically the M962160‑0020A model. This direct OEM match eliminates the guesswork that often comes with third‑party replacements, ensuring a seamless fit and finish.

Best for: Those prioritizing quality and willing to pay for premium performance — the Gcbcrit Shower Handle offers Height: 2.0 inches

Avoid if: You're on a tight budget or only need basic functionality

TL;DR: The American Standard Lever Handle offers a polished chrome look, solid brass build, and a 4.60‑inch length for $24.05, making it a durable yet slightly pricey replacement for Colony Soft lavatory faucets.

This handle’s most eye‑catching dimension is its 4.60‑inch length, paired with a 2.30‑inch width and a 1.90‑inch height. The brass construction, finished in polished chrome, gives it a sleek appearance that resists tarnishing and adds structural strength.

Compared with the six other handles in the roundup, it sits a touch shorter than the Gcbcrit Shower Handle’s 2.0‑inch height, but it stretches longer at 4.60 inches versus Gcbcrit’s 4.2 inches and is wider than its 2.0‑inch width. It is markedly lighter than the Danco American Standard Handle, which weighs 0.15 lb, while the American Standard lever weighs just 0.01 lb. Pricing is on par with Gcbcrit’s $24.99 tag, yet it sits above the budget‑friendly Danco and BrassCraft options.

Professional reviewers highlight the polished chrome finish as a modern touch that stays bright, and the brass body as a guarantee of long‑term durability. Users appreciate the corrosion‑resistant material and the exact fit for the Colony Soft two‑handle widespread bathroom lavatory faucet. The downside is the limited availability of detailed installation dimensions, which can make verification a bit tricky, and the modest pool of nine reviews leaves some buyers wanting more community feedback.

Technically, this lever is designed exclusively for the American Standard Colony Soft faucet, comes as a single count, and carries a one‑year limited warranty. Its lever style matches the original design, and the polished chrome finish aligns with typical bathroom décor.

Best for: Those prioritizing quality and willing to pay for premium performance — the American Standard Lever Handle offers Height: 1.90 inches

Avoid if: You're on a tight budget or only need basic functionality

TL;DR: The Insihay Lever Handle offers a polished‑chrome lever 5.0 inches long, fits American Standard Cadet 8115/8114 faucets, includes a mounting kit, and retails for $19.99 with a 4.1‑star rating.

This handle’s most noticeable dimension is its 5.0‑inch lever length, paired with a 2.0‑inch height and a 2.2‑inch width, all finished in polished chrome. The lever‑type design works with single‑lever pressure‑balance bath and shower faucets, and the package comes with a mounting kit so you don’t need extra parts.

Compared with the seven other handles in this roundup, the Insihay is longer than the Gcbcrit Shower Handle (4.2 inches) and the Hansengroyi Shower Handle (4.2 inches). It also sits a touch wider than Gcbcrit’s 2.0‑inch width, while remaining narrower than the American Standard Colony Handle’s 2.30‑inch width. Height‑wise it matches Gcbcrit’s 2.0‑inch profile but is taller than the American Standard Lever Handle’s 1.90‑inch height. Price‑wise it lands in the mid‑range tier, a bit higher than the Danco American Standard Handle but lower than premium brass options.

Reviewers appreciate that the kit includes everything needed for installation, noting the polished chrome finish adds a sleek look to the bathroom. However, the product’s data sheet is sparse—material and weight aren’t listed, and there are no professional reviews to reference. The modest seven‑review count still yields a respectable 4.1‑star rating, suggesting most owners are satisfied with the basic fit and finish.

From a technical standpoint, the handle operates a single‑lever pressure‑balance valve, which helps maintain consistent water temperature during use. Its lever style aligns with standard American Standard Cadet models (8115/8114), making it a straightforward replacement for those specific faucets.

Best for: Most users seeking a balanced, mainstream option — the Insihay Lever Handle offers Height: 2.0 inches

Avoid if: You need detailed technical specs, professional assessments, or a handle for a faucet brand other than American Standard Cadet 8115/8114

TL;DR: The BrassCraft Heritage Handle delivers a solid brass, chrome‑finished tub/shower lever at 2.8 in height and 4.25 in length, weighing 0.3 lb, and earns a perfect 5‑star rating for just $10.53.

The standout dimension is its 4.25‑inch length, which gives you ample lever travel while keeping the overall profile compact at a 2.8‑inch height. Weighing 0.3 lb, the handle feels sturdy in hand and is built from brass, a material known for durability.

Compared with the six other handles in this roundup, BrassCraft is longer than the Danco model’s 3.74 in lever and matches the Gcbcrit handle’s 4.2‑inch length. Its 2.8‑inch height sits above the 2.0‑inch heights of the Insihay and Hansengroyi options, yet it is shorter than Danco’s 5.13‑inch profile. At 0.3 lb, it is heavier than Danco’s 0.15 lb and far heavier than the ultra‑light American Standard Lever handle, which tips the scales at just 0.01 lb.

User sentiment is overwhelmingly positive: three reviewers have awarded a flawless 5‑star rating, praising the durable brass construction and the polished chrome finish that blends well with modern bathrooms. Reviewers also note the convenience of the included hot, cold, and diverter caps, which simplify installation on American Standard Heritage faucets. The main caveat is the small review pool, leaving some buyers wanting more feedback.

Beyond dimensions, the handle boasts true corrosion resistance and a lever‑type operation that fits tub and shower applications. It arrives as a single count, ready to replace a worn‑out Heritage handle without additional parts.

Best for: Entry-level buyers or those on a tight budget — the BrassCraft Heritage Handle offers Height: 2.8 inches

Avoid if: You want the best value‑per‑dollar in its price range

TL;DR: The Hansengroyi single‑lever shower handle offers a compact 2.0‑inch height, 4.2‑inch length, zinc‑alloy durability and precise temperature control for $20.99, though it sits at a premium price point.

At just 2.0 Inches tall and 4.2 Inches long, this handle packs a comfortable grip into a modest footprint while the 2.0 Inches width keeps the lever easy to maneuver. Its zinc‑alloy construction, finished in polished chrome, promises resistance to daily wear and a sleek look that blends with most bathroom décors.

Compared with the other six handles in the roundup, the Hansengroyi matches the Gcbcrit model in every listed dimension and material, but it lacks the extra length of the Insihay lever (which runs longer than 4.2 Inches) and the taller profile of the BrassCraft Heritage (which stands taller than 2.0 Inches). The Danco option is noticeably larger overall, while the American Standard Lever Handle sits slightly shorter at under 2.0 Inches high. In short, Hansengroyi sits in the middle of the size spectrum, offering a balanced profile without the bulk of the larger units.

Customer feedback is limited—only three reviews—but those reviewers awarded a solid 4.6‑out‑5 rating, highlighting the “precise control” of temperature and flow. The product’s DIY‑friendly installation means you don’t need a professional to swap it out, which aligns with the “easy install” claim in the feature list. Compatibility is locked to the American Standard M962160‑0020A series, ensuring a direct fit for that specific faucet line.

Beyond dimensions, the handle’s single‑lever design consolidates temperature and flow adjustments into one motion, simplifying your shower routine. The smooth polished surface not only looks modern but also feels comfortable under wet hands. Because it’s built from zinc alloy, you get a sturdy lever that should outlast cheaper plastic alternatives.

Best for: Those prioritizing quality and willing to pay for premium performance — the Hansengroyi Shower Handle offers Height: 2.0 Inches.

Avoid if: You're shopping on a tight budget — it's priced at $20.99.