Best Wall-Mount Key Safes

TL;DR: At $49.19, Kidde AccessPoint earns a 4.7‑star rating from over 5,400 reviewers, placing it third in our key‑safe roundup and praised for its durable metal build and easy push‑button combo.

Kidde’s AccessPoint sits at a mid‑range price point of $49.19 and carries a strong 4.7‑out of 5 rating based on 5,428 user reviews. In our six‑product comparison it ranks #3 with a score of 61 out of 100, indicating solid overall performance among its peers.

Customers consistently highlight the double‑wall metal construction as a key strength, noting that it feels robust and resists tampering. The push‑button combination system is also frequently mentioned for its simplicity and the ability to change the code easily. Reviewers appreciate that the unit can be mounted permanently on walls or flat surfaces, making it a discreet solution for families and service providers.

While the box is praised for durability, several users point out practical limits: it isn’t water‑resistant, so heavy rain or submersion could be problematic. The permanent‑mount design means you can’t relocate it without tools, and the capacity is limited to just two keys, which may not suit larger households or teams.

Best for: Buyers willing to invest in a proven, high-quality option — the Kidde AccessPoint is available at $49.19

TL;DR: The Master Lock 5423EC offers a rugged metal box, waterproof cover and a resettable 12‑character push‑button keypad for just $32.92, making it a solid, budget‑friendly choice for permanent key storage.

The standout feature is its push‑button keypad that accepts up to 12 alphanumeric characters and can be reset at any time. A metal body protects the interior, while the vinyl‑coated shackle prevents scratches. The box holds five keys in a 7.9 cubic‑inch interior (3.5 in high × 2.25 in wide × 1 in deep) and measures 4.58 in high × 3.125 in wide × 2.06 in deep. At 2 lb (0.91 kg) it feels sturdy enough for outdoor use, and the waterproof cover adds confidence in wet climates.

Compared with the other five safes in this roundup, the 5423EC is heavier than the Master Lock 5401EC, KeyGuard SL‑590 and Kidde AccessPoint, but lighter than the premium Master Lock 5441EC. Its exterior depth of 2.06 inches exceeds the 1.50‑inch depth of the 5401EC, giving it a larger interior volume (7.9 cubic inches versus 7.3 cubic inches). While the 5401EC and Kidde models are a bit slimmer, the 5423EC’s extra depth translates into more room for bulkier keys or access cards.

Professional reviewers highlight the box’s durability and weather‑resistant cover, noting that the large buttons are easy to press even with gloves or in low‑light conditions. Users echo this sentiment, praising the simple installation and the peace of mind that comes with a lifetime warranty. The most common complaints revolve around the fixed wall‑mount design, which limits placement flexibility, and the lack of a backlit keypad, which can be tricky in total darkness. Some reviewers also mention occasional keypad sensitivity when temperatures plunge.

Additional technical context includes a waterproof rating that protects the contents from rain or splashes, and a resettable code feature that lets you change the combination whenever needed. The lock type is a push‑button keypad, and it requires no hub or smart app, keeping the setup straightforward.

Best for: Most users looking for a well‑reviewed, reliable mainstream option — the Master Lock 5423EC offers Exterior Depth: 2.06 inches (5.2 cm)

Avoid if: You have limited desk space or need portability

TL;DR: The Master Lock 5401EC is a compact, weather‑resistant wall‑mount lock box with a 4‑digit combo, holding up to five keys, and weighs just 1.09 lb, earning a 4.7‑star rating.

The 5401EC packs a durable metal body into a modest 4.72 inches high, 3.27 inches wide and 1.50 inches deep enclosure. Its set‑your‑own 4‑digit combination lets you choose a code you’ll remember, while the vinyl‑coated shackle and weather‑resistant cover keep the dial functional in rain or snow. Inside, the box offers 7.3 cubic inches of volume and room for five keys.

At 1.09 lb, the 5401EC is lighter than the Master Lock 5423EC (1.7 lb) and a touch lighter than the KeyGuard SL‑590 (1.2 lb), yet it’s a shade heavier than the Kidde AccessPoint (1.0 lb). Its five‑key capacity matches the 5423EC, giving you comparable storage without the extra bulk.

Reviewers consistently rate the lock 4.7 out of 5 stars across more than 6,500 reviews, praising the solid metal construction and the weather cover that prevents the dial from freezing. Users also note the built‑in key‑jamming prevention as a practical safety feature.

Beyond the basics, the 5401EC features a resettable code, a lifetime warranty, and a wall‑mount design that suits permanent installations at garages, sheds or entryways. It lacks any smart‑app integration, keeping the product simple and mechanical.

Best for: Budget-conscious buyers seeking a reliable entry-level option — the Master Lock 5401EC offers Master Carton Quantity: 4

Avoid if: You have limited desk space or need portability

TL;DR: At $18.99 the Oria Lock Box earns a 4.6‑star rating from 995 reviewers, praised for its weather‑proof build and flexible mounting, though its internal space is modest.

The Oria Lock Box comes from the Oria brand and sits at the budget end of this six‑product roundup, priced at $18.99 and ranked sixth with a score of 40/100. Its 4.6‑out of‑5 rating, based on 995 reviews, places it just behind the higher‑priced competitors.

Reviewers consistently highlight the box’s durable zinc‑alloy construction and water‑resistant design, saying it feels sturdy enough for outdoor or exposed locations. The removable steel shackle earns compliments for allowing mounting on doors, fences, or even a backpack, adding convenience for homeowners, landlords, and outdoor enthusiasts. A common downside mentioned is that the interior can only hold a few standard keys, which may be insufficient for users needing larger storage.

Given its low price and solid user sentiment, the Oria Lock Box is the most affordable entry in this group. While it lacks independent security certifications and detailed professional reviews, the high review count and positive comments suggest it delivers reliable basic protection for key management.

Best for: Budget-conscious buyers seeking a reliable entry‑level option — the Oria Lock Box is available at $18.99

TL;DR: The Master Lock 5441EC costs $186.14, weighs about 2.6 lb, and offers Bluetooth access with military‑grade encryption and weather‑resistant metal construction for high‑security key storage.

This wall‑mount lock box stands out for its Bluetooth range of 30‑100 ft and a military‑grade encryption standard that protects against both physical tampering and digital hacks. It also includes a numeric keypad backup, supports up to 10 locks in the Home app, and can store five keys. The unit measures 205.7 mm deep, 53.6 mm high and 134.6 mm wide, and it runs on a CR123A battery.

Compared with the other five models in this roundup, the 5441EC is the most expensive and the heaviest at roughly 2.6 lb. It is noticeably bulkier than the Kidde AccessPoint, KeyGuard SL‑590, Master Lock 5423EC, Master Lock 5401EC and Oria Lock Box, all of which weigh between 1.0 lb and 1.7 lb. While the competitors rely on mechanical codes or simple key slots, the 5441EC adds Bluetooth connectivity, a tamper alert system and an audit trail—features not listed for the peers.

Professional reviewers praise the “unmatched security features including military‑grade encryption and tamper alerts,” and everyday users highlight the convenience of sharing access codes with guests or service providers. However, several owners mention occasional Bluetooth connection drops in low‑signal environments, and the bulkier metal housing makes it less portable for on‑the‑go use. The lock’s weather‑resistant rating and operating range down to –40 °C suit outdoor installations, and the resettable code lets you change the combination whenever needed.

Best for: Those prioritizing quality and willing to pay for premium performance — the Master Lock 5441EC offers Master Carton Quantity: 12

Avoid if: Reliability and user satisfaction are your top concerns

TL;DR: At $39.95, the KeyGuard SL‑590 earns a 4.6‑star rating from nearly 2,000 reviewers, who praise its sturdy build and flexible keypad while warning about lockout risk.

The KeyGuard SL‑590 is a wall‑mounted key lock box from the KeyGuard brand, priced at $39.95. It holds a 4.6‑out‑of‑5 rating based on 1,997 reviews and lands at rank #5 with a score of 45 out of 100 in this six‑product roundup. Compared with peers, it sits between the lower‑priced Oria Lock Box at $18.99 and the higher‑priced Kidde AccessPoint at $49.19, offering a mid‑range price point while maintaining a strong rating.

Customers consistently highlight the heavy‑duty metal frame and the ability to store multiple keys, cards and keyfobs in a single compartment. The push‑button keypad, which accepts both letters and numbers, is praised for making memorable combinations easy to set and change. Reviewers also note the removable protective cover that shields the keypad from rain, dust and debris, and they appreciate the weather‑resistant design that keeps the unit functional through cold and heat. The resettable combination mechanism is described as intuitive, letting users adjust codes without fear of permanent lockout—provided they remember the new code.

In practice, the SL‑590 fits a niche for users who want a reliable, well‑reviewed lock box without breaking the bank. Its rating outperforms several higher‑priced options, yet the lack of published dimensions and weight means you’ll need to verify fitment for your specific wall space. Installation also calls for appropriate anchors and tools, which may add a small extra step for DIY installers.

Best for: Most users looking for a well‑reviewed, reliable mainstream option — the KeyGuard SL-590 is available at $39.95