PricepectAI-Verified Comparisons

Comparisons About

⌘K

Pricepect

Independent product comparisons to help you buy smarter.

Browse

Categories
Comparisons
Spec Comparisons
Head-to-Head
Search

Info

About
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service

Top Categories

Electronics
Home & Kitchen
Sports & Outdoors
Automotive

✓ Independent & Unbiased✓ AI-Verified Data✓ Expert-Reviewed

Pricepect participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. © 2026 Pricepect. All rights reserved.

GSI Outdoors Guidecast 5qt Dutch Oven — Review & Specs | Pricepect | Pricepect

Home Cast Iron CookwareGSI Outdoors Guidecast 5qt Dutch Oven

GSI Outdoors Guidecast 5qt Dutch Oven — image 1

GSI Outdoors

GSI Outdoors Guidecast 5qt Dutch Oven

Expert Review Analysis

The GSI Outdoors Guidecast 5qt Dutch Oven is a lightweight cast‑iron oven that weighs about 10 lb, offering traditional heat retention with a 25‑40% weight reduction. Its flat, polished bottom and included three‑leg fire stand make it versatile for campfires, stovetops, induction burners, and ovens.

✓ Best for: Backcountry guides, river/pack trip cooks, and campers who prioritize weight savings without sacrificing cast‑iron heat retention; ideal for backpacking, multi‑day river trips, campfire baking, stovetop searing, and induction cooking at home.✗ Not ideal for: Cookers who need a large flat searing surface, those who prefer built‑in legs for direct coal placement, or users who want dishwasher‑safe cookware.

Pros

✓25‑40% lighter than traditional cast‑iron Dutch ovens, reducing pack weight for backpacking.
✓Corrosion‑resistant finish and polished interior/exterior bottom allow use on campfires, stoves, induction cooktops, and ovens.
✓

Price History

Current

$79.95

Average

$67.94

Lowest

$49.66

Highest

$98.28

Price trend (90d):+12.6%

Best Seller Rank History

Now#825Best#256Worst#1,089 +84

Lower = better sales rank

Rating Trend

Rating4.4/ 5Reviews22+8 reviews +0.31

Specifications

Accessories

Included AccessoriesThree-leg universal fire stand/trivet

Trivet Weight0.3 lbs g

Design

Height7.2 in mm

Width11.8 in mm

Length11.8 in mm

MaterialLightweight cast iron

FinishCorrosion-resistant

General

BrandGSI Outdoors

Model60600

Capacity5 quarts

WarrantyLifetime

CompatibilityCampfire, stove, induction, oven, glass top

Construction

MaterialLightweight cast iron (25‑40% lighter than traditional cast iron)

Finish

CoatingCorrosion‑resistant finish with polished interior and exterior bottom

Handle

DesignSturdy handle with notch for tripod hanging

Base

ShapeFlat bottom (no legs) enabling stove‑top and induction use

Dimensions & Weight

Height7.2 inches

Width11.8 inches

Depth11.8 inches

Weight10.1 pounds

Research Sources

greatlakesoutfitters.ca

gsioutdoors.com

expeditionsuperstore.com

northwestoutlet.com

justroughinit.com

Similar Products

Pruning Saw with Scabbard Japanese Fixed Straight Hand Saw, Portable Tree Limb Cutter 11 Inch Blade Garden Pruner tool for Camping, Dry Wood and Fruit Trees

EDGING CASTING Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Camping Dutch Ovens, Outdoor Camping Dutch Oven Pot with Lid Tripod, 6 Quart

EDGING CASTING Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Camping Dutch Ovens, Outdoor Camping Dutch Oven Pot with Lid Tripod, 6 Quart

EDGING CASTING

HODRANT Heat Deflector Carrying Bag Compatible with Solo Stove Bonfire Heat Deflector 25”, Protective Accessory Bag with Handle & Pocket for Heat Deflector Transport and Storage, Dia: 26.5”, Medium

HODRANT Heat Deflector Carrying Bag Compatible with Solo Stove Bonfire Heat Deflector 25”, Protective Accessory Bag with Handle & Pocket for Heat Deflector Transport and Storage, Dia: 26.5”, Medium

HODRANT

TOMO Cast Iron Oval Bread Oven, ...

Bloomhouse - Two Time Oprah's Favorite Things Winner - 6 Quart Heavy Duty Aluminum Premium PFA Free Ceramic Nonstick Dutch Oven Pot with Lid - Cappuccino Cream with Gold Handle

Bloomhouse - Two Time Oprah's Favorite Things Winner - 6 Quart Heavy Duty Aluminum Premium PFA Free Ceramic Nonstick Dutch Oven Pot with Lid - Cappuccino Cream with Gold Handle

bloomhouse

Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven fo...

Oval Enameled Dutch Oven for Bre...

User Reviews

Please sign in to leave a review

Sort by:

No reviews yet. Be the first to review!

4.1

(14 reviews)

$79.95$89.9511% off

Track Price on BigBangPrice

Get notified when the price drops. Track this product on BigBangPrice, our price tracking partner.

60600Multi-Coloured5 Quart Lifetime warranty against manufacturer defects

Cast Iron Cookware

Flat bottom design provides stability on stovetops and eliminates the need for legs, while the included three‑leg fire stand adds versatility.

✓Sturdy handle with a notch enables easy hanging from a tripod or suspension system during backcountry cooking.

✓Durable lightweight cast iron construction promises long‑term durability and heat retention comparable to heavier models.

Cons

✗Rounded bottom reduces the effective cooking surface area for browning and searing compared to flat‑bottomed ovens.
✗Handle can become extremely hot during use, requiring protective gloves or mitts.
✗Absence of built‑in legs means a separate trivet is required for coals or charcoal, adding an extra component to carry.
✗Cleaning requires hand washing with warm water and salt, then thorough drying; not dishwasher safe.

From Expert Reviews

Praised by Experts

✓Professional reviewers highlight the 25‑40% weight savings while maintaining traditional cast‑iron heat retention, making it ideal for guide‑level trips.
✓Experts praise the flat, polished bottom for its versatility across campfires, stovetops, induction burners, and conventional ovens.
✓Reviewers note the inclusion of a stable three‑leg fire stand as a valuable accessory for charcoal and coals management.

Criticized by Experts

✗Reviewers point out that the rounded bottom limits the searing surface, making it less optimal for high‑heat browning tasks.
✗Professional tests mention the handle becoming dangerously hot, necessitating additional protection during cooking.

From User Reviews

Users Love

✓Backcountry users appreciate the significant weight reduction, allowing them to keep a Dutch oven on self‑supported trips without extra bulk.
✓Campers mention the easy maintenance routine of hand washing with salt and water, finding it straightforward after use.
✓Outdoor enthusiasts value the ability to use the oven on induction stovetops at home, expanding its utility beyond the campsite.

Users Complain About

✗Some users note the need for a separate trivet due to the lack of built‑in legs, adding another piece to pack.
✗A few campers report the handle heating up quickly, requiring them to use gloves while stirring or serving.

Expert Opinion

Professional reviewers commend the Guidecast for delivering the heat‑retention performance of traditional cast iron while shedding 25‑40% of the weight, a game‑changer for guides and lightweight backpackers. They also appreciate the flat, polished bottom that works on a wide range of cooking surfaces and the bundled three‑leg fire stand, though they caution that the rounded bottom limits searing area and the handle can become very hot.

What Users Say

Everyday users praise the oven’s portability and versatility, especially its ability to be taken on self‑supported trips and used on induction stovetops. The most common feedback highlights the need for a separate trivet and the hot handle, but overall sentiment is positive with no major recurring complaints.

Common Complaints

Handle becomes extremely hot during use, rounded bottom reduces searing surface area, and the lack of built‑in legs necessitates carrying a separate trivet.

What People Are Saying

“fantastic choice”
YouTube gear tester

“no reason to ditch Dutch oven cooking on self‑support trips”
online forum

How It Compares

vs. Lodge 5qt Traditional Cast Iron Dutch Oven

Advantages

✓Superior heat retention due to thicker cast iron mass
✓Built‑in legs allow direct placement of coals without a separate trivet
✓Robust construction ideal for stationary camp setups

Disadvantages

✗Heavier at ~14‑15 lb, adding significant pack weight
✗Less versatile on stovetops and induction burners due to legs
✗Bulkier dimensions make it harder to pack

Choose Lodge if you prioritize maximum heat retention and don’t mind the extra weight; choose Guidecast for lightweight backpacking and multi‑surface use.

vs. GSI Anodized Aluminum 5qt Dutch Oven

Advantages

✓Very light (~3‑5 lb) for ultralight packers
✓Aluminum heats up quickly for fast cooking
✓No seasoning required, easy to clean

Disadvantages

✗Lower heat retention than cast iron, cooling faster when food is removed
✗Less durable over long term compared to cast iron
✗May not perform as well for low‑and‑slow baking

Select the aluminum model for speed and ultralight weight; select the Guidecast when you need better heat retention and durability without the full weight of traditional cast iron.