PricepectAI-Verified Comparisons

Comparisons About

⌘K

Pricepect

Independent product comparisons to help you buy smarter.

Browse

Categories
Comparisons
Spec Comparisons
Head-to-Head
Search

Info

About
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service

Top Categories

Electronics
Home & Kitchen
Sports & Outdoors
Automotive

✓ Independent & Unbiased✓ AI-Verified Data✓ Expert-Reviewed

Pricepect participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. © 2026 Pricepect. All rights reserved.

KeyGuard SL-500 Black — Review & Specs | Pricepect | Pricepect

Home Key SafesKeyGuard SL-500 Black

KeyGuard SL-500 Black — image 1

KeyGuard

KeyGuard SL-500 Black

Expert Review Analysis

The KeyGuard SL-500 is a portable punch-button lock box designed for secure, keyless access to keys, fobs, cards, and IDs. It features a durable solid metal vault with an ABS plastic coating, a phone-style keypad for alphanumeric combinations, and a shackle for attachment to door knobs or handles.

✓ Best for: Realtors, property managers, vacation rental owners, caregivers, and homeowners needing temporary key access for guests, family, or service providers. Specific use cases include securing house keys on door knobs for showings, vacation rentals, or in-home care, and storing fobs/IDs without supervision.✗ Not ideal for: Users requiring exact exterior dimensions or shackle diameter specifications for precise fitting, or those who prefer dial-based combination systems over push-button interfaces.

Pros

✓Spacious interior storage fits multiple keys, fobs, cards, or IDs without capacity issues
✓Phone-style push-button keypad allows for memorable 4-7 character alphanumeric combinations
✓

Best Seller Rank History

Now#500Best#342Worst#507 -148

Lower = better sales rank

Rating Trend

Rating4.2/ 5Reviews1,034+-3 reviews -0.20

Specifications

Keypad

Combination Length4-7 characters

Code TypeNumeric or Alphabetic

Security

Padlock Loop Width¾” (19 mm)

Construction

Coating MaterialABS plastic over solid metal

Dimensions & Weight

Height2.6771653516 inches

Width0.8267716527 inches

Depth1.574803148 inches

Weight1.0 pounds

Research Sources

fjmsecurity.com

clksupplies.com

lakenormansigncompany.com

sanzospecialties.com

Similar Products

KeyGuard SL-590 Punch Button Lock Box - Secure Wall Mount Key Storage for Homes, Offices, and Rentals

KeyGuard SL-590 Punch Button Lock Box - Secure Wall Mount Key Storage for Homes, Offices, and Rentals

KeyGuard

KeyGuard SL-501 Punch Button Lock Box | Portable Shackle LockBox For Outside - Fits House Keys, Car Keys, Fobs, & More | Keypad Safe Box, Digital Push Button Combination Lock | Black Finish

KeyGuard SL-501 Punch Button Lock Box | Portable Shackle LockBox For Outside - Fits House Keys, Car Keys, Fobs, & More | Keypad Safe Box, Digital Push Button Combination Lock | Black Finish

KeyGuard

KeyGuard SL-591 Car Window Punch Button Lock Box, Black- Portable Key Storage Vault LockBox Fits House Keys, Car Keys, Fobs, Credit Cards/IDs + | Rideshare Keypad Safe Box, Digital Push Button Lock

KeyGuard SL-591 Car Window Punch Button Lock Box, Black- Portable Key Storage Vault LockBox Fits House Keys, Car Keys, Fobs, Credit Cards/IDs + | Rideshare Keypad Safe Box, Digital Push Button Lock

KeyGuard

KeyGuard Pro SL-590-Cvr Outdoor Lock Box with Protective Rubber Cover Medium

KeyGuard Pro SL-590-Cvr Outdoor Lock Box with Protective Rubber Cover Medium

KeyGuard Pro

Kayme Car Cover Straps Wind Protector,3pcs Elastic Adjustable Rope Protect Cover from High Wind, Universal Fit

Kayme Car Cover Straps Wind Protector,3pcs Elastic Adjustable Rope Protect Cover from High Wind, Universal Fit

kayme

Mul-T-Lock Traka 21 Plug and Play Key Management Solution Standalone Touchscreen with 21 iFobs and Seals Key Cabinet

Mul-T-Lock Traka 21 Plug and Play Key Management Solution Standalone Touchscreen with 21 iFobs and Seals Key Cabinet

Mul-T-Lock

RUDY RUN Key Lock Box for Outside - Wall Mount Combination Lockbox for House Keys Outdoor

RUDY RUN Key Lock Box for Outside - Wall Mount Combination Lockbox for House Keys Outdoor

RUDY RUN

Key Lock Box for Outside - Realtor Lockbox for House Keys Outdoor - Combination Key Hiders to Hide a Key Safe Storage

Key Lock Box for Outside - Realtor Lockbox for House Keys Outdoor - Combination Key Hiders to Hide a Key Safe Storage

RUDY RUN

XDeer 45-Key Biometric Lock Box,...

BGL Bathroom Accessory Set Brushed Nickel 4-Pieces Bathroom Towel Rack 24 Inches Adjustable Bathroom Hardware Set

BGL Bathroom Accessory Set Brushed Nickel 4-Pieces Bathroom Towel Rack 24 Inches Adjustable Bathroom Hardware Set

BGL

Iron Lock® Key Lock Box Portable with Cable Shackle – Waterproof Heavy Duty Metal Lock Box for Keys with 4-Digit Combination & Resettable Code – Outdoor/Indoor Key Safe for Outside Use (Grey, Small)

Iron Lock® Key Lock Box Portable with Cable Shackle – Waterproof Heavy Duty Metal Lock Box for Keys with 4-Digit Combination & Resettable Code – Outdoor/Indoor Key Safe for Outside Use (Grey, Small)

Iron Lock

Iron Lock® Key Lock Box Portable with Cable Shackle & Wall Mount – Waterproof Heavy Duty Metal Lock Box for Keys with 4-Digit Combination & Resettable Code – Outdoor/Indoor Key Safe (Black, XXL)

Iron Lock® Key Lock Box Portable with Cable Shackle & Wall Mount – Waterproof Heavy Duty Metal Lock Box for Keys with 4-Digit Combination & Resettable Code – Outdoor/Indoor Key Safe (Black, XXL)

Iron Lock

Key Lock Box for Outside - Lock Box for House Keys - Key Lockbox for Key Storage Outdoor, 4 Digit Combination Lock Box for Outside Realtors Garage Spare Keys

Key Lock Box for Outside - Lock Box for House Keys - Key Lockbox for Key Storage Outdoor, 4 Digit Combination Lock Box for Outside Realtors Garage Spare Keys

mafiti

TOLEBLID 144 Position Key Lock Box Wall Mount with Combination Lock, Digital Key Cabinet Wall Mount, Adjustable Key Safe for Car, Hotels, Office, House

TOLEBLID 144 Position Key Lock Box Wall Mount with Combination Lock, Digital Key Cabinet Wall Mount, Adjustable Key Safe for Car, Hotels, Office, House

TOLEBLID

Upgrade SL-591 Car Key Lock Box, Car Window Lock Box for Turo, Car Window Punch Button LockBox, Vehicle Window Key Box, Vehicle Window Lock Box fit for Ride Share, Turo, GetAround,10 Year Warranty

Upgrade SL-591 Car Key Lock Box, Car Window Lock Box for Turo, Car Window Punch Button LockBox, Vehicle Window Key Box, Vehicle Window Lock Box fit for Ride Share, Turo, GetAround,10 Year Warranty

BNRSZ

Iron Lock® Wall Mount Key Lock Box – Waterproof Heavy Duty Metal Lock Box for Keys with 4-Digit Combination & Resettable Code – Outdoor/Indoor Key Safe for Home, Office & Airbnb (Black, Small)

Iron Lock® Wall Mount Key Lock Box – Waterproof Heavy Duty Metal Lock Box for Keys with 4-Digit Combination & Resettable Code – Outdoor/Indoor Key Safe for Home, Office & Airbnb (Black, Small)

Iron Lock

Key Lock Box for Keys with Code (24 Pack) 4 Digit Combination Lockbox for Keys Outdoor, Portable, Waterproof, Realtor Lock Box, Black

Key Lock Box for Keys with Code (24 Pack) 4 Digit Combination Lockbox for Keys Outdoor, Portable, Waterproof, Realtor Lock Box, Black

Lion Locks

[New]Smart Lock Box,CATCHFACE Wireless Smart Key Lock Box App Control,Share eKey,Key Lockbox Wall Mount&Door Handle,Electronic LockBox Realtor/Home/Office/Warehouse/Vrbo/Cars

[New]Smart Lock Box,CATCHFACE Wireless Smart Key Lock Box App Control,Share eKey,Key Lockbox Wall Mount&Door Handle,Electronic LockBox Realtor/Home/Office/Warehouse/Vrbo/Cars

CATCHFACE

2025 Upgrade SL-591 Car Lock Box, Car Window Punch Button Lock Box for Ride Share, Turo, GetAround (Black)

2025 Upgrade SL-591 Car Lock Box, Car Window Punch Button Lock Box for Ride Share, Turo, GetAround (Black)

Casmer

Heavy Duty 103 Keys Electronic K...

Featured in Comparisons

Best Portable/Outdoor Key Safes

Best Portable/Outdoor Key Safes

roundup

KeyGuard SL-500 Black vs Rudy RUN Lock Box

pairwise

Master Lock 5406D vs KeyGuard SL-500 Black

pairwise

User Reviews

Please sign in to leave a review

Sort by:

No reviews yet. Be the first to review!

4.4

(1,037 reviews)

$33.95

SL-500BlackShackle 1 year warranty

Tough ABS plastic coating over solid metal vault provides scratch resistance and weather durability

✓Protective flap over the keypad shields buttons from dirt and accidental presses

✓Optional ¾” wide padlock loop on the release tab adds an extra layer of security

Cons

✗Combination setup requires precise button rotation to 6 o'clock position or it fails
✗Must pull reset button next to 0 to open after incorrect entries, which can be cumbersome
✗No exact overall exterior dimensions or shackle diameter specified in available sources
✗Lack of direct consumer reviews makes long-term reliability harder to verify
✗Setup process is less intuitive than dial-based systems due to specific rotation requirements

From Expert Reviews

Praised by Experts

✓Larger storage capacity compared to basic models allows for a lot of room to put anything needed
✓Intuitive phone keypad design supports alpha-numeric codes for easier memorization
✓Protective coating prevents door scratches during attachment and removal
✓Sturdy and secure construction ideal for realtors and property managers
✓Easy shackle release mechanism via a metal push piece for quick access

Criticized by Experts

✗Combination setup requires precise button rotation to 6 o'clock position or it fails
✗Must pull reset button next to 0 to open after incorrect entries, which can be cumbersome

From User Reviews

Users Love

✓Fits a handful of keys with space left over, avoiding denting in capacity
✓Easy-to-use keypad avoids spinning dials, making codes memorable and simple

Expert Opinion

Professional reviewers and editors praise the KeyGuard SL-500 for its superior storage capacity, intuitive phone-style keypad that supports alphanumeric codes, and protective coating that prevents door scratches. CLK Supplies highlights the roomy interior and easy shackle release, while FJM Security and Lake Norman Sign Co. emphasize its secure construction and suitability for realtors and property managers needing temporary key access.

What Users Say

Search results lack direct consumer reviews or feedback. Demos simulate a positive user experience, noting the ease of fitting a handful of keys with space left over, but no recurring praise or complaints from actual buyers are documented.

Common Complaints

Combination setup requires precise button rotation to 6 o'clock position or it fails. Must pull reset button next to 0 to open after incorrect entries, which can be cumbersome

How It Compares

vs. Master Lock 5400D

Advantages

✓Supports alpha-numeric codes instead of numeric only
✓Larger interior storage dimensions (3.75" x 2.5" x 0.5") compared to ~2.2" x 2.5" x 1"

Disadvantages

✗Requires precise button rotation for setup unlike dial unlock
✗More complex setup process than rotating dial systems

Choose the KeyGuard SL-500 for larger storage and memorable alphanumeric codes, or the Master Lock 5400D for simpler numeric dial operation.

vs. Kidde 001787 Shackle Box

Advantages

✓Supports alpha-numeric codes instead of numeric only
✓Includes protective flap over keypad for added protection

Disadvantages

✗Requires precise button rotation for setup unlike standard button unlock
✗More complex setup process than standard push-button systems

Choose the KeyGuard SL-500 for enhanced code flexibility and keypad protection, or the Kidde 001787 for standard numeric push-button simplicity.

KeyGuard SL-500 Black vs Master Lock 5423EC

pairwise

Kidde AccessPoint vs KeyGuard SL-500 Black

pairwise

KeyGuard SL-500 Black vs Master Lock 5440EC

pairwise

Master Lock 5400EC Black vs KeyGuard SL-500 Black

pairwise

Master Lock 5401EC vs KeyGuard SL-500 Black

pairwise

KeyGuard SL-500 Black vs Master Lock 5422E

pairwise

Kidde TouchPoint vs KeyGuard SL-500 Black

pairwise

KeyGuard SL-500 Black vs Oria Lock Box

pairwise