Amazon Basics 1.24 Cu Ft Safe
Score: 75/100
Master Lock STW205
Score: 87/100Rankings
The Master Lock STW205GYC is a premium home security solution featuring UL-classified fire protection and ETL-verified water resistance. It combines robust steel construction with a programmable digital keypad to deter theft while protecting documents. While it offers excellent security and convenience, its limited water depth protection and battery dependency are notable trade-offs.
The Amazon Basics Fire Resistant Security Safe is a steel safe designed for securing valuables and documents, featuring a programmable electronic keypad and UL 72 certified fire resistance. It is explicitly not waterproof and is intended primarily for theft deterrence and basic fire protection in low-risk environments. It is best suited for homeowners or small office users needing basic fire-resistant storage in apartments without flood risk.
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
20 minutes | 120 minutesbest | |
1,200 degrees_fahrenheit | 1,850 degrees_fahrenheitbest | |
2,143.68 cubic_inches | 3,456 cubic_inchesbest | |
| ↓ lower better | 19.67 inchesbest | 23.8 inches |
| ↓ lower better | 14.17 inchesbest | 18.6 inches |
| ↓ lower better | 13.8 inchesbest | 19.3 inches |
| ↓ lower better | 66.99 poundsbest | 192 pounds |
— | 1,440 minutesbest |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
Fire Protection(2) | ||
Fire Rating Duration (minutes) | 20 minutes | 120 minutes |
Fire Rating Temperature (degrees_fahrenheit) | 1200 degrees_fahrenheit | 1850 degrees_fahrenheit |
Compliance & Safety(1) | ||
Certifications | UL 72 | UL, ETL |
Dimensions & Capacity(4) | ||
Interior Capacity (cubic_inches) | 2143.68 cubic_inches | 3456 cubic_inches |
Exterior Height (inches) | 19.67 inches | 23.8 inches |
Exterior Width (inches) | 14.17 inches | 18.6 inches |
Exterior Depth (inches) | 13.8 inches | 19.3 inches |
Build & Portability(1) | ||
Weight (pounds) | 66.99 pounds | 192 pounds |
Security & Locking(2) | ||
Lock Type | Electronic Keypad | Digital Keypad |
Backup Access | Key | Battery Backup |
Installation & Support(1) | ||
Warranty Length (years) | 1 years | Lifetime years |
Products in the top-left offer the best value (high score, low price).
Professional reviewers and editors note that the safe is primarily designed for theft security rather than comprehensive fireproofing. While it offers a UL 72 fire rating, experts clarify that it is not fireproof or waterproof in non-fire contexts and recommend alternatives for users needing full protection against floods or high-value item security.
There is no specific user review data available in the source material. Inferred sentiment suggests potential praise for the simplicity of the electronic keypad and the value of the fire resistance, while potential complaints may arise from size discrepancies between listed models or the lack of waterproofing.
Manufacturer and retailer descriptions position this safe as offering the best protection in its class, citing unmatched performance through UL and ETL certifications. Professional highlights emphasize the high-grade steel construction, pry-resistant hinges, and century-old innovation.
Search results lack direct user reviews, but specs imply praise for reliability, particularly regarding multi-user convenience and durable steel construction.
