Amazon Basics 5-Tier Shelving
Score: 88/100Edsal 5-Tier Garage Shelving
Score: 88/100Rankings
The Amazon Basics 4000 lb Heavy Duty Adjustable Storage Shelving Unit is a robust, five-shelf aluminum wire rack designed for high-capacity storage in garages and workshops. It offers exceptional load capacity and versatile configuration options. However, users must be cautious with uneven loads, as concentrated weight can cause shelf bending.
The Edsal Heavy Duty Garage Shelf is a robust, 5-level steel shelving unit designed for high-capacity storage in garages and offices. Its standout feature is the massive 800 lbs per-shelf capacity, though the particle board shelves may sag under uneven loads. It is best suited for homeowners needing to store heavy tools, bins, or bulk items.
| Attribute | | Edsal 5-Tier Garage Shelving |
|---|---|---|
60 inchesbest | 48 inches | |
78 inchesbest | 72 inches | |
4,000 lbsbest | 4,000 lbsbest | |
24 inchesbest | 24 inchesbest | |
5best | 5best | |
800 lbsbest | 800 lbsbest | |
| ↓ lower better | 30 minutesbest | 60 minutes |
| ↓ lower better | 72.75 lbsbest | 74 lbs |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | Edsal 5-Tier Garage Shelving |
|---|---|---|
Dimensions(2) | ||
Overall Width (inches) | 60 inches | 48 inches |
Overall Height (inches) | 78 inches | 72 inches |
Assembly & Installation(2) | ||
Assembly Time (minutes) | 30 minutes | 60 minutes |
Installation Type | Floor Mount | Freestanding |
Build & Material(3) | ||
Primary Material | Aluminum/Steel | Steel/Particle Board |
Finish Type | Anodized | Powder-Coated |
Product Weight (lbs) | 72.75 lbs | 74 lbs |
Features & Usability(2) | ||
Intended Use | Multi-purpose | Garage/Industrial |
Stackable | true | false |
Search results lack dedicated professional editor reviews from major publications for this specific model. However, YouTube assembly reviews generally praise the unit's sturdiness and adjustability. Experts note that while the construction is robust, the maximum load claims assume ideal even distribution, and real-world testing reveals flex under concentrated weight.
Everyday consumers commonly praise the shelving unit's sturdiness, durability, and customizable shelf heights, particularly for garage organization tasks like hanging hoses. Recurring complaints focus on the load limits being optimistic for uneven distribution, with users reporting bending when weight is concentrated in the center, and the necessity for exact leveling during assembly.
Professional reviewers and retailers highlight the Edsal shelving for its heavy-duty steel construction, Z-Beam design for strength, and boltless rivet-lock assembly.
Common themes from similar Edsal shelving units suggest users praise durability and capacity but often note challenges with assembly.
