Rankings
The Ciays Large Propane Fire Pit delivers a powerful 58,000 BTU output in a compact, portable design, featuring a piezo ignition, lid, and cover for convenience. It lacks a removable ash pan and spark screen, which may affect cleanup and safety. Ideal for users seeking a high-heat propane pit that's easy to transport.
The Shintenchi R9061 is a 43-inch rectangular propane fire pit table providing 50,000 BTU, complete with a lid, glass wind guard, and waterproof cover, and backed by CSA certification. Its weight and size make it less portable, and ignition details are unspecified. Suited for patios or gardens where a robust, certified fire table is desired.
The Solo Stove Mesa XL is a tiny tabletop fire pit that delivers a smokeless burn thanks to its 360° airflow and offers dual-fuel flexibility in a ultra-light package. Its 7-inch bowl and sub-hour burn time limit heat for bigger parties, and it lacks a gas option. Ideal for balconies, patios or small gardens where portability and low smoke are paramount.
The Ciays CIFPT21B-32 is a compact 32-inch square propane fire pit table delivering a powerful 50,000 BTU heat output. It lacks a wind guard and does not include a propane tank, and its dimension listings are inconsistent. Ideal for homeowners seeking a portable, dual-purpose fire pit/table for small-to-medium outdoor gatherings.
The SereneLife fire pit offers a portable 26-inch steel bowl that doubles as a BBQ grill. It is limited to wood or charcoal fuel, and inconsistent dimensions may cause planning issues. Ideal for casual outdoor enthusiasts seeking a lightweight, no-assembly fire pit with grilling capability.
The Gas One 22-inch Wood Burning Fire Pit is an ultra-lightweight, budget-friendly option with a mesh lid and fire picker for safe operation. It provides limited heat output details and lacks accessories such as a cover or ash pan. Perfect for small patios or camping trips where portability matters most.
The Bali Outdoors wood-burning fire pit offers a solid steel build and a generous 32-inch fire bowl for outdoor cooking. It requires assembly, a protective deck sheet, and its 28-lb weight reduces portability. Best suited for backyard gatherings where a sturdy, feature-rich wood fire pit is desired.
The Verdeluxe 36-inch Fire Pit combines a robust iron build with dual cooking grills and a lid, creating a versatile outdoor cooking station. Its substantial weight and lack of portability, plus missing performance specifications, limit flexibility. Suited for permanent backyard setups where durability and cooking capability are key.
The Sunnydaze 36-Inch Outdoor Fire Pit Ring provides a lightweight, steel construction with a diamond-cutout design that promotes strong airflow for efficient wood fires. It does not include safety accessories like a cover or spark screen, limiting its ready-to-use convenience. Best suited for campers and casual backyard users who prioritize portability.
The LEMY 32-inch Outdoor Fire Pit Table offers a sturdy steel-mesh construction with a built-in lid, spark screen, and PVC rain cover, delivering reliable wood-burning performance for backyard gatherings. However, its 30 lb weight and lack of an ignition system make it less portable and require manual lighting. Ideal for permanent patio setups where durability and accessories matter.
| Attribute | | | | | | | | | | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
— | — | 58,000 BTU/hbest | — | — | 50,000 BTU/h | 50,000 BTU/h | — | — | — | |
8.6 in | 19.4 in | 10 in | 20 in | 10 in | 24.5 in | 25 in | 25 in | 41.7 inbest | 20 in | |
7 in | 31.6 in | 20 in | 21.5 in | 36 in | 43 inbest | 32 in | 36 in | 27.5 in | 26 in | |
7 in | 31.6 in | 20 in | 21.5 in | 36 in | 22 in | 32 in | 36 in | 27.5 in | 226 inbest | |
| ↓ lower better | 2.3 lbbest | 30.4 lb | 23 lb | 11.8 lb | 15 lb | 59 lb | 36.6 lb | 33 lb | 28 lb | 20 lb |
— | — | — | — | 36 inbest | — | — | — | 32 in | 26 in | |
— | — | — | — | 1 yearsbest | — | — | — | — | — |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | | | | | | | | | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Design(5) | ||||||||||
Height (in) | 8.6 in | 19.4 in | 10 in | 20 in | 10 in | 24.5 in | 25 in | 25 in | 41.7 in | 20 in |
Width (in) | 7 in | 31.6 in | 20 in | 21.5 in | 36 in | 43 in | 32 in | 36 in | 27.5 in | 26 in |
Length (in) | 7 in | 31.6 in | 20 in | 21.5 in | 36 in | 22 in | 32 in | 36 in | 27.5 in | 226 in |
Weight (lb) | 2.3 lb | 30.4 lb | 23 lb | 11.8 lb | 15 lb | 59 lb | 36.6 lb | 33 lb | 28 lb | 20 lb |
Material | 304 stainless steel | Steel mesh and frame | Cast iron grate, steel body | Alloy steel with high-temperature paint | Steel | Alloy Steel | Steel frame, Texteline panels, stainless‑steel burner | Heavy-duty steel | Metal | Steel |
Features(6) | ||||||||||
Fuel Type | Dual (Wood, Pellets) | Wood | Propane | Wood | Wood | Propane | Propane | Wood | Wood | Wood |
Heat Output (BTU/h) | — | — | 58000 BTU/h | — | — | 50000 BTU/h | 50000 BTU/h | — | — | — |
Portable | true | — | true | true | true | — | true | false | true | true |
Removable Ash Pan | true | — | false | — | — | — | — | — | true | — |
Airflow Technology | 360° Airflow | — | — | — | Improved airflow | — | — | — | — | — |
Fire Bowl Diameter (in) | — | — | — | — | 36 in | — | — | — | 32 in | 26 in |
General(1) | ||||||||||
Certifications | — | — | CSA Certified | — | — | CSA | CSA | — | — | — |
Products in the top-left offer the best value (high score, low price).
Professional reviewers describe the Mesa XL as a remarkable addition for stylish, smokeless outdoor ambiance, emphasizing its efficient 360° airflow, durable stainless-steel construction, and dual-fuel versatility. They note the extended pellet capacity and compact yet powerful design make it especially suited for urban patios and small gatherings.
Everyday users consistently praise the Mesa XL for its compact portability, low-smoke operation, and ability to provide cozy warmth for small groups, often mentioning frequent use and the convenience of the included stand and bag. Complaints are minor, focusing on limited fire size for larger parties and occasional confusion over weight specifications.
“We love it and use it all the time”
“97% recommend it”
“stays put but not too heavy... excellent touch!”
Choose Solo Stove for efficient, propane-compatible burning; choose SereneLife for a lower-cost, all-steel, grill-ready option.
Professional retailers and editors emphasize the KF-DCR36's durable steel construction, lightweight portability, and ideal 36-inch diameter, positioning it as an affordable, functional option for simple wood-burning fires, though they note the omission of safety and cooking accessories.
Everyday users appreciate the ring's size, weight, and attractive diamond pattern, highlighting easy handling and good airflow, while commonly wishing for added accessories such as a spark screen or cooking grate and expressing mild concerns about long-term rust resistance.
Professional and editorial sources praise the CIFPT21B-32 for its solid steel build, high heat output, and the convenience of a removable lid that turns the unit into a serving table. The included lava rocks and easy propane hookup are highlighted as value-adding accessories, while the CSA certification reassures users of its safety compliance.
Professional reviewers commend the Bali Outdoors 32-inch fire pit for its robust steel build, generous cooking area, and thoughtful features like a swiveling grill and log rack, noting it offers excellent value and easy assembly. The reviewer emphasizes its durability under high heat and suitability for outdoor barbecuing, while no major drawbacks were highlighted in the professional assessment.
Everyday users consistently praise the fire pit for being affordable, attractive, and functional, highlighting its solid feel, ample cooking space, and useful accessories. The main user-reported concern is the need for a protective metal sheet when placing the pit on decks to avoid ember damage, and some note the assembly effort and weight as minor inconveniences.
