Rankings
The BLACK+DECKER GD2051B offers 1500 W power, a slide-out warming tray, and a removable temperature probe for precise cooking. Its size and weight may be challenging for very small kitchens, and the non-stick surface requires careful utensil use. Best for families needing a reliable, feature-rich griddle for batch breakfasts.
The Presto 07062 22-inch Ceramic Griddle features a spacious cooking area, removable handles, and a durable cast-aluminum base with ceramic non-stick coating. Its bulkier dimensions can challenge storage and countertop space. Suited for large families or entertainers who need ample cooking surface and easy storage.
The Hamilton Beach 38522 offers a roomy 200 sq in reversible ceramic griddle with adjustable 200-400°F temperature control, making it ideal for batch cooking. Missing power specifications and grease management limit its performance insight. Best for families needing large capacity and easy-clean removable plates.
The Presto 07061 features an extra-large 22-inch cooking surface and a cast-aluminum base for even heating, catering to family-size meals. Its single heat zone and absence of a temperature readout limit cooking flexibility. Great for households needing big-batch breakfast cooking.
The Hamilton Beach 3-in-1 Indoor Grill/Griddle offers a versatile reversible cooking surface and a spacious 180 sq in area, highlighted by dishwasher-safe nonstick plates. Its fixed height, relatively short cord and moderate weight limit flexibility for some users. Best suited for small families seeking an all-in-one countertop solution.
The Presto 07046 Tilt'nDrain griddle provides a generous 285 sq in cooking area with a unique tilt mechanism for easy grease removal. Its bulky size and limited review data may pose storage and confidence concerns. Suited for large families or entertainers requiring high-volume cooking.
The GreenPan Advanced Electric Griddle features a large PFAS-free ceramic surface and a built-in warming drawer, delivering healthy, convenient cooking for families. Its short power cord and lack of clear warranty information are notable drawbacks. Best suited for health-focused home cooks who value a warming drawer and easy cleanup.
The Presto 07023 XL Cool-Touch Griddle offers a spacious square ceramic surface and versatile multi-function tray, making it ideal for compact kitchens. Its basic temperature control and spec inconsistencies limit precision and confidence. Best suited for small families or individuals needing a compact, multi-purpose griddle.
GreenLife's 20" electric griddle provides a spacious PFAS-free ceramic nonstick surface and adjustable temperature dial, delivering quick, even heating for family breakfasts. Its main drawbacks are the lack of dishwasher-safe components and a relatively short power cord. Best suited for health-conscious home kitchens.
| Attribute | | | | | | | | | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1,500 Wbest | — | — | — | — | 1,400 W | 1,500 Wbest | — | — | |
1,845 cm²best | 1,355 cm² | — | 1,633 cm² | 1,838.71 cm² | 1,161.29 cm² | 1,355 cm² | 1,290.32 cm² | 1,354.84 cm² | |
| ↓ lower better | 2.25 kg | 2.75 kg | 2.59 kg | 2.59 kg | 3.18 kg | 4.08 kg | 1.92 kgbest | 2.59 kg | 3.79 kg |
204.44 °C | — | — | — | — | 218.33 °Cbest | — | 204.44 °C | — | |
— | — | — | — | — | 1 yearsbest | — | — | — |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | | | | | | | | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Controls(1) | |||||||||
Temperature Control Type | Dial | basic | automatic | automatic | automatic | Dial | Dial | Dial | Knob |
Power & Performance(3) | |||||||||
Wattage (W) | 1500 W | — | — | — | — | 1400 W | 1500 W | — | — |
Maximum Temperature (°C) | 400°F °C | — | — | — | — | 218°C °C | — | 204°C °C | — |
Power Type | Electric | — | electric | electric | electric | Electric | Electric | Electric | Electric |
Design & Build(4) | |||||||||
Weight (kg) | 4.96 lb kg | 2.75 kg | 2.59 kg | 2.59 kg | 3.18 kg | 4.08 kg kg | 1.92 kg | 2.59 kg kg | 3.79 kg kg |
Overall Dimensions (L×W×H) (mm) | 330.2 x 88.9 x 558.8 mm mm | 414x489x76 mm mm | 343×667×64 mm mm | 342.0 x 72.9 x 663.5 mm mm | 607×130×470 mm mm | 584 x 318 x 170 mm mm | 589.8×289.9×70.1 mm mm | 673 x 272 x 89 mm mm | 615 x 327 x 125 mm mm |
Plate Material | Non‑stick | Ceramic | cast aluminum | cast aluminum | ceramic | Ceramic (PFAS-free) | — | Durathon ceramic (PFAS-free) | Ceramic (PFAS-Free) |
Cooking Surface Area (cm²) | 286 in^2 cm² | 1355 cm² cm² | — | 1633 cm² | 1838.71 cm² | 1161 cm² cm² | 1355 cm² | 1290 cm² cm² | 1355 cm² cm² |
Features(2) | |||||||||
Dishwasher Safe | true | — | — | true | — | true | false | true | true |
Removable Handles | false | — | true | true | — | — | false | — | — |
Products in the top-left offer the best value (high score, low price).
Professional reviewers highlight the GD205B's combination of rapid, uniform heating and adjustable temperature via a removable probe, noting its durable PFAS-free ceramic coating and the convenience of a slide-out warming tray. They also emphasize the ease of cleanup provided by the removable drip tray and dishwasher-safe base, positioning it as a reliable, family-focused kitchen appliance.
Everyday users consistently praise the griddle's large cooking area and the warming tray that keeps food hot while the rest cooks. The non-stick surface receives positive remarks for easy pancake flipping and minimal residue, while the quick-clean features are frequently mentioned as a major convenience.
“highly recommended”
“perfect for indoor cooking”
Professional editors position the Presto 07023 as a best-selling, versatile electric griddle, praising its square cooking surface for efficiency and its multi-function tray that expands its use beyond simple frying.
Limited consumer feedback (two 5-star reviews) consistently praises overall performance and ease of cleaning, with no specific complaints reported.
Professional reviewers consider the Presto 07062 a strong performer for large-household cooking, emphasizing its spacious surface, durable construction, and health-friendly nonstick coating. The primary criticism centers on its bulkiness, which can limit portability and countertop fit in smaller kitchens.
Everyday users give the Presto 07046 high marks, highlighting the roomy cooking surface as a major advantage for feeding multiple people at once.
Professional product pages and retailer descriptions emphasize the grill's versatility, large cooking area, and easy-clean features, positioning it as an award-winning indoor solution that delivers even heat up to 425 °F with dual temperature zones.
Everyday users praise the unit for its convenience, especially the reversible plates and straightforward cleanup, noting it works well for full family breakfasts and quick indoor grilling, with limited negative feedback.
Professional reviewers and editors, though limited, highlight the griddle's large XL surface, rapid 1500 W heating, health-focused PFAS-free ceramic coating, and easy-clean removable drip tray, positioning it as a stylish, functional addition for home kitchens.
Everyday shoppers appreciate the generous cooking area, quick heat-up, and non-stick performance, often noting the attractive pink color, while the need to hand-wash the surface and inconsistent weight listings are common points of frustration.
