Rankings
The Proctor Silex SureCut Electric Automatic Can Opener is a corded countertop unit featuring SureCut technology, automatic shutoff, and built-in cord storage for reliable hands-free opening of standard and extra-tall cans. While it delivers strong performance and many accessories, it lacks portability and requires a 120 V outlet. Ideal for home cooks who frequently open a variety of cans and value stability.
The Cuisinart SCO-60 provides a sturdy brushed stainless-steel build, extra-wide base, and one-touch operation with added accessories like a knife sharpener. Its large size, weight, and need for hand-only cleaning may deter some users. Perfect for frequent can-opening in high-volume or premium kitchens.
The Hamilton Beach OpenStation offers SureCut technology, automatic shutoff, and integrated jar-opening tools in a compact countertop design. Its heavier build and lack of extensive third-party reviews could be drawbacks for some users. It excels for seniors and small-kitchen users needing multifunctional convenience.
The Hamilton Beach Extra-Tall Electric Automatic Can Opener offers hands-free operation, auto-shutoff and extra-tall can support. Its reliance on a cord and plastic body limit portability and perceived durability. Best for households needing versatile tall-can opening without worrying about battery life.
The Oster electric can opener combines a patented Power Pierce blade with stainless-steel durability, automatically shutting off and handling tall cans. Manual cord wrap-around storage and a modest knife sharpener are trade-offs. Suited for households that frequently open tall cans and value sturdy construction.
The Hamilton Beach Smooth Edge electric can opener uses a side-cutting blade to produce smooth, reusable lids and handles tall cans up to 6 inches. Its short power cord and reported durability issues may limit long-term use. Ideal for home cooks seeking safe, one-hand operation.
The ELITRA HOME 3-in-1 under-cabinet opener offers space-saving mounting and 4-in-1 tools for cans, bottles, and knives. However, it is extremely noisy and has reported reliability problems. It's aimed at space-constrained kitchens where noise isn't a primary concern.
| Attribute | | | | | | | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ↓ lower better | 290 gbest | 1,838 g | 816 g | 1,180 g | 1,030 g | 1,151 g | 1,179 g |
— | — | — | 120 Vbest | — | 120 Vbest | — | |
| ↓ lower better | — | 60 Wbest | — | 70 W | — | — | — |
1 years | 3 yearsbest | 1 years | 3 yearsbest | — | 1 years | 1 years | |
1 | — | — | 4best | — | 3 | — |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | | | | | | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Power & Battery(3) | |||||||
Power Source | Electric | Electric | Corded electric | corded | Mains | Electric | ac |
Voltage (V) | — | — | — | 120 V | — | 120 V | 220-240 V |
Power Consumption (W) | — | 60 W | — | 70 W | — | — | — |
General Specs(1) | |||||||
Warranty (years) | 1 years | 3 years | 1 years | 3 years | — | 1 years | 1 years |
Features(3) | |||||||
Quiet Operation | true | — | — | — | false | — | — |
Cutting Mechanism | Side-cutting | — | — | surecut | side-cut | — | power_pierce |
Can Size Compatibility | Up to 6 inches | — | All sizes including extra‑tall | 30 oz | All | Standard | tall |
Accessories(1) | |||||||
Number of Included Accessories | 1 | — | — | 4 | — | 3 | — |
Design & Build(6) | |||||||
Blade Material | Stainless steel | Stainless steel | Stainless Steel | high-carbon stainless steel | Stainless steel | — | stainless_steel |
Blade Type | — | Power Cut | — | — | side-cut | — | — |
Body Material | Plastic | Brushed stainless steel | Plastic | — | Plastic and stainless steel | Plastic, Stainless steel | — |
Weight (g) | 290 g | 1838 g | 816 g | 1180 g | 1030 g | 1151 g | 1179 g |
Overall Dimensions (H×W×D) (cm) | Height 25.9-26.7 cm × Width 11.9-12.7 cm × Depth 11.9-12.7 cm cm | 24.77×11.43×11.43 cm cm | 22.9×14.5×11.7 cm cm | 15.4×26.2×12.6 cm cm | 11.4×17.8×17.8 cm cm | 14.9×23.2×11.5 cm cm | 15.24 x 12.7 x 25.4 cm |
Mount Type | Freestanding | Freestanding | Freestanding countertop | countertop | Under-cabinet | — | — |
Products in the top-left offer the best value (high score, low price).
Professional reviewers commend the Hamilton Beach Smooth Touch for its side-cutting safety, ergonomic lever, and mess-free operation, positioning it as a convenient kitchen essential for busy households. However, they caution that the short cord and reported short-term durability make it less suitable for heavy or commercial use, and they note that not all models include an automatic shutoff.
Everyday users love the ease of one-handed operation, the smooth, non-sharp lids, and the ability to open tall cans, often describing the device as a noticeable upgrade over handheld openers. Recurring complaints focus on the short power cord, occasional mechanical failures after a month of use, and occasional metal shavings, leading some to question long-term reliability.
“easy and simple”
“what a difference over handheld”
“smooth edges”
Professional reviewers consistently commend the SCO-60 for its sturdy, extra-wide base that prevents tipping, the precision Power Cut blade that delivers clean cuts, and the premium brushed stainless-steel construction. They also highlight the convenience of one-touch, hands-free operation and useful accessories like the magnetic lid holder, while noting the safety issue of sharp lid edges and the requirement for hand-only cleaning.
Everyday users echo the professional praise for stability and ease of use, describing the opener as heavy, reliable, and 'pretty slick' when opening large cans. The removable lever and magnetic lid holder are appreciated for simplifying cleanup, though users also mention the sharpness of lids and the inconvenience of hand-washing the unit.
No direct professional reviews were found; Hamilton Beach markets the opener as the #1 best-selling U.S. can opener brand based on NPD Group data through June 2021, emphasizing ease of use and versatility.
Consumer feedback is sparse but generally positive, highlighting reliable performance across all can sizes, easy cleaning thanks to the detachable lever, and the convenience of cord storage.
Professional reviewers and retailer editors emphasize the SureCut™ blade's patented strength and the unit's extra-tall height as key differentiators, highlighting the built-in knife sharpener, cord storage, and automatic shutoff as features that boost everyday kitchen efficiency.
Everyday users consistently commend the opener's speed, reliability, and hands-free convenience, often describing it as the best they've owned. The most common feedback mentions occasional stabilization needs for unusually large cans, but overall satisfaction is high.
Professional retailer pages present the Elitra Home as a space-saving, multifunctional solution for small kitchens, emphasizing its automatic operation and durable build, but they provide no independent testing or detailed power specifications, leaving its performance largely unverified.
Everyday users generally like the convenience and multifunctionality, especially for limited kitchen space and accessibility needs, but the overwhelming negative feedback centers on extreme noise levels and occasional reliability failures.
Professional reviewers and editors have little in-depth analysis of the OpenStation, but manufacturer statements stress its reliable first-time opening and multifunctional design. The lack of detailed third-party testing is noted, though the product is positioned as a practical, all-in-one kitchen tool.
Everyday users overwhelmingly praise the OpenStation for its ease of use, especially for seniors, its compact footprint, and the convenience of built-in jar openers and a multi-tool. While no major complaints surface, the limited number of reviews creates some uncertainty about long-term performance.
Professional reviewers commend the Oster opener for its patented Power Pierce blade, stainless-steel durability, and tall-can compatibility, noting that the auto shut-off and hands-free design make it especially convenient. However, they point out that the built-in knife sharpener is only modestly effective and that the manual cord storage feels less refined than retractable alternatives.
Everyday users echo the professional praise for effortless tall-can opening, clean cuts, and hands-free convenience, while consistently reporting that the knife sharpener offers only limited sharpening and that the cord storage is fiddly to manage.
