Rankings
The Schlage Z-Wave Connect Camelot deadbolt offers high-security Grade AAA construction, Z-Wave Plus connectivity and a built-in alarm for robust smart home integration. Its dependence on an external Z-Wave hub and a modest code capacity may deter users seeking standalone Wi-Fi solutions. Ideal for homeowners who already use a Z-Wave hub and prioritize security and alarm features.
The Kwikset SmartCode 916 provides Z-Wave Plus connectivity, a touchscreen keypad, and SmartKey rekeying in a solid metal package. Its discontinuation and reliance on a hub for remote and voice functions limit future support. It fits homeowners who already have a Z-Wave hub and value on-lock programming.
The Yale Assure SL is a keyless deadbolt featuring a backlit capacitive touchscreen and built-in Z-Wave connectivity, offering robust smart-home integration for standard doors. Its lack of native Wi-Fi or Bluetooth means additional modules are needed for broader connectivity. Ideal for homeowners who prioritize Z-Wave ecosystems and a sleek retrofit design.
The Yale Assure Lock SL is an ultra-slim, key-free deadbolt with a backlit touchscreen and optional Z-Wave integration, delivering sleek aesthetics and solid BHMA Grade 2 security. Its lack of native Wi-Fi and a short one-year electronics warranty limit its smart-home convenience. Best suited for homeowners seeking a minimalist design who don't mind adding a hub for connectivity.
| Attribute | | | | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
— | — | — | 8,760 hoursbest | |
— | — | — | 43 mmbest | |
3 yearsbest | 1 years | — | — | |
— | — | — | 65 mmbest | |
| ↓ lower better | 3,629 g | 1,360.8 gbest | 1,361 g | 1,538 g |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | | | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Battery & Power(2) | ||||
Battery Type | — | AA alkaline (4), 9V backup | AA alkaline | AA |
Power Source | Battery | AA alkaline batteries with 9V backup | Battery | Battery |
Security(1) | ||||
Security Grade | Grade AAA/Commercial 1 | Grade 2 | — | Grade 2 |
Fit & Design(5) | ||||
Door Thickness Compatibility (mm) | 35-44 mm | — | 35-57 mm | 43 mm |
Backset (mm) | 60-70 mm | — | 60-70 mm | 65 mm |
Weight (g) | 3629 g | 1360.8 g | 1361 g | 1538 g |
Material | Solid brass/steel | Zinc | Zinc | Metal |
Finish | Aged Bronze | Satin Nickel | Oil Rubbed Bronze | — |
General(2) | ||||
Warranty (years) | 3 years | 1 years | — | — |
Certifications | ANSI/BHMA Grade AAA, ANSI/BHMA A156.36‑2010/2015 Commercial Grade 1 | BHMA Grade 2 (ANSI/BHMA A156.36 certified) | — | ANSI/BHMA Grade 2, UL 20‑minute fire rating |
Products in the top-left offer the best value (high score, low price).
Professional reviewers commend the Yale SL for its ultra-slim aesthetic, solid BHMA Grade 2 construction, and quiet motorized operation, positioning it as a premium, reliable choice for key-free entry. However, they note the limited electronics warranty and the absence of native Wi-Fi as drawbacks that require optional modules for full smart-home integration.
Everyday owners love the convenience of programmable PIN codes, the easy DIY installation, and the stylish satin-nickel finish, while recurring concerns focus on battery life, menu navigation quirks, and the need for extra hardware for thin doors or Wi-Fi connectivity.
Professional reviewers commend the Kwikset 916 for its solid build quality, straightforward installation, and dependable Z-Wave Plus connectivity that works well with popular hubs. However, they criticize the on-lock only code programming and the lack of native voice-assistant support, and they warn that the product's discontinuation could limit future updates and support.
Everyday users generally like the ease of DIY installation, the responsive touchscreen, and the reliable hub notifications for battery status. Recurring complaints focus on the inability to manage codes remotely, occasional hub pairing hiccups, and concerns about the lock being discontinued, which raises doubts about long-term support.
“Easy installation with basic tools”
