Coleman NorthStar
Score: 82/100
Etekcity LED Camping Lantern
Score: 72/100Rankings
The Coleman NorthStar 1500 Lumens is a propane-powered camping lantern designed for reliable outdoor illumination, featuring matchless ignition and a PerfectFlow regulator for extreme weather. It delivers a powerful 1,500 lumens but has a limited 4-hour runtime on high settings and requires a separate propane cylinder. It is ideal for family camping trips and backyard gatherings requiring bright, weather-resistant area lighting.
The Etekcity Camping Lantern is a compact, collapsible LED lantern powered by AA batteries, designed for portability and emergency use. Its main trade-off is lower maximum brightness compared to rechargeable models and the ongoing cost of disposable batteries. It is best suited for casual campers and hikers who prioritize lightweight gear over high-output illumination.
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
1,500 lumensbest | 280 lumens | |
4 hours | 30 hoursbest | |
| ↓ lower better | 942.13 grams | 199 gramsbest |
5 yearsbest | 2 years | |
306.07 mmbest | 141 mm |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
Battery & Power(2) | ||
Battery Runtime (hours) | 4 hours | 30 hours |
Power Source | Propane | AA Batteries |
Build & Durability(4) | ||
Ingress Protection Rating | IPX5 | |
Housing Material | Aluminum | ABS Plastic |
Weight (grams) | 942.13 grams | 199 grams |
Warranty Length (years) | 5 years | 2 years |
Design & Usability(3) | ||
Mounting Options | Tabletop/Standing | Magnetic Base, Hanging |
Height (mm) | 306.07 mm | 141 mm |
Handle Type | Collapsible | |
Performance & Lighting(3) | ||
Maximum Brightness (lumens) | 1500 lumens | 280 lumens |
Light Modes | Adjustable | 4 Levels |
Light Source Type | Mantle | LED |
Products in the top-left offer the best value (high score, low price).
No direct quotes from professional reviewers or editors are available in the search results. One non-professional YouTube reviewer praised it as a shiny new upgrade from an older Coleman lantern, highlighting the 1,500 lumens output and ease of #95 mantle installation.
Search results contain no consumer reviews, ratings, or testimonials. Common praise or complaints cannot be identified from available data.
Professional reviewers praise the compact collapsibility, adjustable brightness, and reliable runtime, noting it is dependable for hiking and emergencies despite lower maximum brightness compared to rivals.
Everyday users commonly praise the ease of use, reliable brightness for tents, and super portable collapsible design, though some complain about faster battery drain with non-alkaline batteries.
