Fire-Maple Fixed Star 1
Score: 73/100
Coleman Butane or Propane Camping Stove
Score: 81/100Rankings
The Coleman Classic 1-Burner stove delivers 7,650 BTU (≈2243 W) with Instastart ignition and a wind baffle, making it reliable for solo cooking. Its limitations include a single burner, short high-heat runtime, and reduced performance in cold weather. Ideal for casual campers and picnickers who need a lightweight, easy-to-use stove.
The Fire-Maple Fixed Star FMS-X1 is a 1 L integrated canister stove system delivering 2200 W and 30% faster boils thanks to heat-exchange fins. Its trade-offs are a heavier package, higher fuel use, and a non-regulated burner that can be slower on low heat. Best for budget-conscious solo or duo hikers who value compactness and speed over ultralight weight.
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
| ↓ lower better | 511 g | 249 gbest |
1best | 1best | |
2,200 W | 2,243 Wbest | |
3 yrbest | 3 yrbest | |
30 %best | — |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
Build & Design(1) | ||
Weight (g) | 511 g | 249 g |
Controls(1) | ||
Ignition Type | Piezo | Instastart |
Power(1) | ||
Power Output (W) | 2200 W | 2243 W |
General(1) | ||
Fuel Type | Canister | Butane/Propane |
Accessories(1) | ||
Included Accessories | Stove, canister stand, lid, cup, mesh bag | Carrying case, Removable porcelain‑coated grate |
Products in the top-left offer the best value (high score, low price).
Professional reviewers commend the FMS-X1 for its all-in-one packaging, durable construction and the 30% efficiency gain from its heat-exchange fins, noting its strong 2200 W output and suitability for beginners. However, they also flag the non-regulated burner's slower 1 L boil times, the relatively heavy weight, and limited fuel canister capacity as drawbacks, especially for cold-weather or ultra-light applications.
Everyday users praise the compact nesting system, reliable piezo start and solid build, describing it as a great value for budget backpacking and everyday cooking. Recurring complaints focus on higher fuel consumption in wind or cold, occasional igniter failures, and the weight being a concern for ultralight hikers.
“extremely satisfied at a fraction of competition price.”
“will last years”
“Lightweight and compact design with a 5.15-lb weight and carry case for easy transport on camping trips.”
Professional reviewers emphasize the stove's strong portability, reliable Instastart ignition, solid wind protection, and sufficient 7,650 BTU output, positioning it as a dependable choice for casual outdoor cooking where weight and ease of use are priorities.
Everyday users overwhelmingly praise the stove for its lightweight build, easy fuel availability, long-term durability, and effective heating, with few complaints and a general sentiment that it performs well for quick, single-pan meals.
