Garmin Vívоactive 5
Score: 82/100
Withings ScanWatch 2
Score: 84/100Rankings
The Withings ScanWatch 2 is a hybrid smartwatch combining analog hands with a grayscale OLED display and up to 30 days of battery life. Its bulkier build and lack of built-in GPS may deter some users. It excels for health-focused individuals needing medical-grade ECG and long-term monitoring.
Garmin's vívoactive 5 is a mid-range smartwatch featuring a bright 1.2-inch AMOLED display, extensive health sensors and up to 11 days of battery life. It omits ECG and dual-frequency GPS, limiting its appeal to serious athletes. Targets fitness enthusiasts who value a rich health suite and music storage without premium navigation features.
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
264 hours | 720 hoursbest | |
| ↓ lower better | 36 gbest | 52 g |
— | 14,504 pxbest | |
1.2 inbest | 0.6 in |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
Battery & Power(1) | ||
Battery Life (hours) | 264 hours | 720 hours |
Build & Design(1) | ||
Weight (g) | 36 g | 52 g |
Display(3) | ||
Screen Size (in) | 1.2 in | 0.6 in |
Display Type | AMOLED | Grayscale OLED |
Resolution (px) | 390x390 px | 14504 px |
Connectivity(1) | ||
Built‑in GPS | true | false |
General(1) | ||
Operating Temperature (°C) | -20 to 60 °C | 5-40 °C |
Products in the top-left offer the best value (high score, low price).
Professional reviewers describe the vívoactive 5 as a well-rounded health-focused smartwatch, applauding its bright AMOLED display, impressive 11-day battery life, and comprehensive suite of health tools like Body Battery and Sleep Coach. They note the inclusion of wheelchair-specific modes as a strong accessibility point, but criticize the absence of a barometric altimeter, ECG, and dual-frequency GPS, which limits its appeal to serious athletes seeking precise elevation data.
Everyday users consistently praise the long battery life, vivid display, and intuitive health insights, especially Body Battery and sleep tracking. While overall sentiment is positive, a few users express disappointment over missing advanced GPS and altitude features, and the lack of disclosed weight creates some uncertainty about comfort.
Professional reviewers commend the ScanWatch for its elegant hybrid aesthetic and clinical-grade health sensors, especially the ECG and high-resolution display on the ScanWatch 2, while noting its standout 30-day battery life. However, they criticize the device's bulk, lack of built-in GPS, and occasional app sync issues, suggesting it excels as a health-focused accessory rather than a full-featured smartwatch.
Everyday users consistently praise the long battery life, accurate health metrics and premium build quality, describing it as comfortable for all-day wear. Recurring complaints focus on the watch's weight, the difficulty of reading the small hidden screen, and occasional connectivity hiccups with the companion app.
