Honeywell Carnegie Industrial
Score: 80/100
Amico 42-inch Ceiling Fan
Score: 70/100Rankings
The Honeywell Carnegie is a 52-inch industrial-style indoor ceiling fan featuring a matte black finish, caged drum light fixture, and reversible dual-finish blades. It offers a quiet, energy-efficient reversible motor with remote control functionality and integrated dimmable LED lighting suitable for rooms up to 400 square feet. It is ideal for energy-conscious users wanting reversible airflow and remote convenience.
The Amico KFM42PLY03R1 is a 42-inch low-profile flush-mount ceiling fan designed for small to medium rooms with ceilings under 9 feet. It features a reversible DC motor for energy-efficient cooling and heating, a dimmable 3CCT LED light, and ultra-quiet operation suitable for bedrooms. It is best suited for users in compact spaces needing quiet, efficient airflow and customizable lighting.
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
52 inchesbest | 42 inches | |
5,046 CFMbest | — | |
450 lumensbest | — | |
2,700 Kbest | — | |
| ↓ lower better | — | 30 dBbest |
3 count | 6 countbest | |
4 inchesbest | 0 inches |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
Dimensions(1) | ||
Fan Diameter (inches) | 52 inches | 42 inches |
Controls(1) | ||
Control Type | remote | Remote |
Lighting(3) | ||
Light Output (Lumens) (lumens) | 450 lumens | lumens |
Color Temperature (K) | 2700 K | 3000-5000 K |
Light Wattage (watts) | unknown watts | watts |
Installation(2) | ||
Mount Type | dual_mount | Flush Mount |
Downrod Length (inches) | 4 inches | 0 inches |
Performance(4) | ||
Airflow (CFM) (CFM) | 5046 CFM | CFM |
Motor Type | reversible | DC |
Fan Speeds (count) | 3 count | 6 count |
Blade Pitch (degrees) | unknown degrees | degrees |
Products in the top-left offer the best value (high score, low price).
Retail editors from major home improvement stores highlight the fan's rugged modern appeal, sleek geometric design, and ultra-efficient airflow.
Search results provide no user reviews, ratings, or testimonials. While the manufacturer notes a 100% satisfaction guarantee, there are no common praises regarding ease of installation or noise levels, nor are there recurring complaints about wobbling or remote issues from buyers.
Sources lack dedicated professional reviews from major outlets like Wirecutter or Consumer Reports. However, product documentation highlights engineering strengths such as the DC motor's quiet efficiency and the low-profile design's suitability for rooms under 9 feet, positioning it as a top pick for compact spaces.
Direct consumer feedback is absent from the provided sources. Implied praise from product descriptions suggests users appreciate the quiet operation for light sleepers and the ease of using the remote control, with no recurring complaints noted.
