Jabsco Macerator Pump
Score: 78/100
Little Giant APCP-1700
Score: 75/100Rankings
The Jabsco 18590-2092 is a high-performance macerator pump designed for efficient waste transfer in marine and RV applications. Its primary limitation is a short 15-minute duty cycle, which can lead to overheating if used continuously. It is best suited for intermittent use cases where quick, clog-resistant emptying is required.
The Little Giant APCP-1700 is a 1/3 HP automatic submersible pump designed to remove standing water from pool covers, boat covers, and flat roofs. It features a mechanical float switch that activates at 2 inches of water and deactivates at 1.5 inches, offering a high flow rate of up to 1745 GPH at low head pressure. While effective for its intended purpose, it is not suitable for continuous duty or dirty water applications.
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
12 GPM | 29.08 GPMbest | |
5 ftbest | — | |
12 V | 115 Vbest | |
— | 0.33 HPbest | |
16 Abest | 2.2 A | |
15 %best | — | |
— | 140 °Fbest | |
| ↓ lower better | 5 lbsbest | 13 lbs |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
Performance & Power(6) | ||
Flow Rate (GPM) | 12 GPM | 29.08 GPM |
Max Pressure (PSI) | PSI | N/A PSI |
Voltage (V) | 12 V | 115 V |
Horsepower (HP) | HP | 0.33 HP |
Max Amperage (A) | 16 A | 2.2 A |
Duty Cycle (%) | 15 % | Intermittent % |
Features & Protection(3) | ||
Dry-Run Protection | true | false |
Thermal Protection | false | N/A |
Warranty Length (months) | months | 36 months |
Build & Durability(5) | ||
Motor Type | Permanent Magnet | PSC |
Weight (lbs) | 5.0 lbs | 13.0 lbs |
Noise Level (dB) | high dB | N/A dB |
Diaphragm Material | Nitrile | N/A |
Valve Material | N/A | |
Installation & Compatibility(4) | ||
Self-Priming Lift (ft) | 5 ft | N/A ft |
Max Liquid Temperature (°F) | °F | 140 °F |
Port Size (in) | 1.5 in | 1.0 in |
Frequency (Hz) | DC Hz | 60 Hz |
Products in the top-left offer the best value (high score, low price).
Marine industry reviewers praise the reliability and 4-blade cutter upgrade, positioning it as a standard for professional marine installations.
Users praise the speed and self-priming features but complain about noise and overheating issues when exceeding the duty cycle.
“Blasts through waste fast-emptied my 40-gal tank in 2.5 min”
“Run-dry saved it when hose clogged”
“Overheats after 10-12 min on big loads”
Professional reviewers and editors highlight the Little Giant APCP-1700 as an industry-leading solution for preventing pool cover damage due to its high flow rate and automatic operation. They praise its energy-efficient motor, quick activation, and robust construction, noting it is ideal for all types of pool covers. However, in-depth expert tests are scarce, with descriptions focusing primarily on specifications rather than hands-on verdicts.
Consumer feedback is sparse but generally positive regarding ease of use and effectiveness. Users commonly praise the pump's portability and ability to remove water quickly. The most recurring complaint is the tendency for the pump to air lock, which stops operation and requires manual fixes, such as using two hoses to prevent air intake.
