Kwikset SmartCode 917 Satin Nickel
Score: 80/100
Philips Smart Lock with Handle
Score: 78/100Rankings
The Kwikset SmartCode 917 is a residential electronic lever lock designed for keyless entry with exceptional battery life and Grade 2 security. It lacks smart home integration and remote access, which is a trade-off for users seeking app-based control. It is best suited for homeowners who want keyless entry without smart-home headaches or app dependency.
The Philips WiFi Keypad Door Lock is a smart deadbolt featuring built-in 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi without requiring a hub, offering multiple unlock methods including fingerprint, PIN, and voice control. It supports up to 100 user PIN codes and 20 fingerprints, with auto-lock capabilities and remote app management for enhanced home security. The lock is ideal for tech-savvy homeowners wanting hub-free Wi-Fi smart locking without wiring.
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
36 monthsbest | 6 months | |
1.75 inchesbest | 1.375 inches | |
2.75 inchesbest | — | |
— | -31 °Fbest |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
Power & Battery(2) | ||
Battery Life (months) | 36 months | 6 months |
Battery Type | 9V Alkaline | AA |
Support & Warranty(1) | ||
Warranty Length (years) | Lifetime (Mechanical/Finish), 1 (Electronics) years | Not Specified years |
Security & Access(4) | ||
Security Grade | Grade 2 / AAA | Grade 3 |
Unlock Methods | Keypad, Key | Fingerprint, Keypad, Physical Key, App |
Keypad Type | Numeric Backlit | Touchscreen |
Encryption Standard | SmartKey | AES128 |
Installation & Compatibility(3) | ||
Door Thickness Compatibility (inches) | 1.75 inches | 1.375-2 inches |
Backset (inches) | 2.375 or 2.75 inches | Not Specified inches |
Installation Type | Lever Deadbolt | DIY |
Connectivity & Smart Features(2) | ||
Smart Home Integration | None | Alexa, Google Assistant |
Wi-Fi Standard | 2.4GHz | |
Build & Durability(4) | ||
Material | Not Specified | |
IP Rating | Not Specified | |
Operating Temperature (°F) | °F | -31-151 °F |
Finish | Satin Nickel | Matte Black |
Products in the top-left offer the best value (high score, low price).
Professional reviewers consistently highlight the Kwikset SmartCode 917's exceptional battery life and simplicity as its top strengths. The Grade 2/AAA BHMA rating and SmartKey security features are repeatedly cited as making it a secure, residential-grade choice compared to cheaper keypads.
Everyday users generally praise the lock's reliability, aesthetics, and ease of programming, noting that the 9 V battery truly lasts multiple years. The auto-lock mode and SmartKey convenience are frequently appreciated for their practicality in homes and rentals. However, recurring complaints focus on the lack of app connectivity, the restrictive first-4-digit code logic, and the absence of entry logs.
“I wish this connected to Alexa/Google/Home.”
“Great for basic keyless entry; not the right pick if you want full smart-home integration.”
“Very good for users who want keyless entry without smart-home complexity.”
Professional reviewers praise the Philips WiFi Keypad Door Lock for its seamless remote control via hub-free Wi-Fi, fast fingerprint recognition, and easy DIY installation. Editors highlight the convenience of voice integration and flexible PIN management, though they note that the reliance on batteries and the Grade 3 security rating are limitations for advanced users requiring higher security standards.
Everyday consumers appreciate the effortless app and voice control, quick fingerprint entry, and the auto-lock feature that prevents forgetting to lock the door. Users find the guest PIN functionality particularly useful for rentals and families. However, recurring complaints focus on battery life draining faster due to Wi-Fi usage and occasional connectivity glitches when not on 2.4 GHz networks.
