Makita BO5041
Score: 85/100
Black+Decker BDERO100 5-inch Black
Score: 72/100Rankings
The Makita BO5041 is a versatile 5-inch random orbit sander with a 3-amp motor and variable speed control, designed for woodworkers and contractors. It features an adjustable handle and low vibration for comfortable use, though it does not include sandpaper in the box. It is best suited for users who need precise speed control for finishing furniture or removing paint.
The BLACK+DECKER BDERO100 is a 2.0 Amp corded 5-inch random orbital sander designed for DIY homeowners and hobbyists. It features a fixed 12000 OPM speed and a hook-and-loop sandpaper system to deliver swirl-free finishes on wood, metal, and plastic surfaces. It is best suited for DIY homeowners, hobbyists, and light professionals tackling surface prep, paint or stain removal, finishing wood/metal/plastic, or shaping.
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
300 Wbest | 240 W | |
12,000 RPMbest | 12,000 RPMbest | |
3.175 mmbest | — | |
122.2 mm | 127 mmbest | |
| ↓ lower better | 1.59 kg | 1.4 kgbest |
3 yearsbest | 2 years |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
Power & Performance(4) | ||
Motor Power (W) | 300 W | 240 W |
Orbit Diameter (mm) | 3.175 mm | mm |
Variable Speed | true | false |
Sanding Pad Diameter (mm) | 122.2 mm | 127 mm |
Ergonomics & Design(4) | ||
Weight (kg) | 1.59 kg | 1.4 kg |
Vibration Reduction | true | false |
Switch Type | Trigger with Lock-On | Dust-sealed |
Handle Type | Adjustable Front Handle | Comfort grip |
Features & Accessories(4) | ||
Dust Collection System | Through-the-Pad | Dust bag |
Warranty (years) | 3 years | 2 years |
Includes Sandpaper | false | true |
Pad Attachment Type | Hook & Loop | Hook-and-loop |
Professional reviewers from Homebuilding.co.uk and YouTube experts highly rate the Makita BO5041 for its superior sanding performance and ergonomic handling. They praise the continuous variable speed dial for allowing users to find a vibration-free sweet spot and appreciate the lock-on button for continuous use.
Everyday users and reviewers highlight the tool's versatility and ease of handling across various materials. The continuous variable speed is frequently cited as a key advantage for finding optimal performance settings. Users appreciate the power for wood sanding but note the necessity of adjusting speeds for delicate materials to avoid burning.
“keep it cranked all the way”
“sweet spot with minimal vibration”
Professional reviewers praise the BDERO100 for its value in DIY finishes, noting that the 12000 OPM speed optimizes removal without creating swirls. The sealed switch is highlighted for boosting durability, while editors emphasize the hook-and-loop ease for professional results. However, reviewers note that the 2.0 Amp motor is best suited for light-to-medium tasks rather than heavy stripping or stock removal.
Everyday users commonly praise the tool for its smooth sanding on small projects, easy dust bag setup, and lightweight design which aids control. Many note that the 12000 OPM speed removes paint and stain quickly from wood. Recurring complaints include the fixed speed leading to over-sanding on delicate surfaces, the dust bag filling up fast without a vacuum hookup, and some reports of vibration during extended use.
