Makita XDT11Z
Score: 78/100
Porter-Cable 20V MAX Impact Driver 4 inch
Score: 72/100Rankings
The Makita XDT11Z is an 18V LXT impact driver featuring a powerful 4-pole motor and durable all-metal gear housing for reliable performance. Its main trade-off is the single speed mode, which limits versatility for delicate tasks. It is best suited for professionals in construction or woodworking who need a compact, high-torque driver within the Makita ecosystem.
The Porter-Cable 20V MAX Impact Driver offers a budget-friendly solution for DIYers with 1,400 in-lbs of torque and fast charging capabilities. The brushed motor is a trade-off for the lower price, leading to shorter runtime and potential heat issues during prolonged use. It is best suited for homeowners and light trade pros needing affordable power for occasional tasks.
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
1,460 in-lbbest | 1,400 in-lb | |
18 V | 20 Vbest | |
2,900 RPMbest | 2,700 RPM | |
3,500 IPMbest | 3,100 IPM | |
| ↓ lower better | 2.2 lbsbest | 4.7 lbs |
— | 1.5 Ahbest | |
| ↓ lower better | 5.375 inbest | 11.4 in |
1 countbest | 1 countbest |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
Performance(3) | ||
Maximum Torque (in-lb) | 1460 in-lb | 1400 in-lb |
Maximum Speed (RPM) (RPM) | 2900 RPM | 2700 RPM |
Impacts Per Minute (IPM) (IPM) | 3500 IPM | 3100 IPM |
Accessories(1) | ||
Includes Battery | false | true |
Build & Design(3) | ||
Tool Weight (lbs) | 2.2 lbs | 4.7 lbs |
Tool Length (in) | 5.375 in | 11.4 in |
Tool Width (in) | 6.18 in | 3.7 in |
Power & Battery(1) | ||
Battery Voltage (V) | 18 V | 20 V |
Features(2) | ||
Chuck Type | 1/4 inch hex | 1/4-inch hex |
Belt Clip | false | null |
Controls(2) | ||
Speed Settings | 1 | Variable |
Trigger Type | Variable | Variable speed |
Products in the top-left offer the best value (high score, low price).
Professional reviewers and editors highlight the Makita XDT11Z as a reliable workhorse within the Makita LXT lineup. Key praised traits include its powerful 4-pole motor, compact ergonomics, and job site durability.
There is no available user review data or feedback from everyday consumers in the provided sources. Consequently, no common praise or complaints from user bases can be identified.
“plenty of power for DIY screws/bolts”
“good torque”
Professional reviewers highlight the Porter-Cable 20V lineup for its value-driven performance, noting strong torque and adequate runtime in brushed models. They praise the tool's compactness for jobsite productivity but note it is not top-tier for professionals needing maximum power.
Everyday users love the lightweight build and ease of use in tight spaces, finding plenty of power for DIY screws and bolts. Recurring complaints include brushed motor heat-up on prolonged use and shorter runtime compared to brushless competitors.
