Makita XSR01Z
Score: 88/100
DeWalt DCS590B
Score: 92/100Rankings
The DEWALT DCS590B is a high-performance 7.25-inch cordless circular saw designed for professional framing and sheet goods cutting. It features a brushless motor with electronic brake and 5,500 RPM, offering corded-like power in a portable format. It is ideal for professional framers and remodelers who require maximum cutting power and depth.
The Makita XSR01Z is a 36V brushless rear-handle circular saw designed as a cordless alternative to corded worm-drive saws, featuring dual 18V batteries and Automatic Speed Change technology. Its primary trade-off is the weight and bulk associated with the dual-battery configuration. It is best suited for professional framers and roofers needing cordless power equivalent to 15-amp corded rear-handle saws.
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
7.25 inchesbest | 7.25 inchesbest | |
2.563 inchesbest | 2.563 inchesbest | |
5,100 RPM | 5,500 RPMbest | |
53 degrees | 57 degreesbest | |
36 Vbest | 20 V | |
| ↓ lower better | 12.9 lbsbest | — |
0.625 inchesbest | 0.625 inchesbest | |
3 yearsbest | 3 yearsbest |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
Power & Motor(2) | ||
Voltage (V) | 36 V | 20 V |
Amperage (A) | A | null A |
Performance & Cutting(2) | ||
No-Load Speed (RPM) | 5100 RPM | 5500 RPM |
Bevel Capacity (degrees) | 53 degrees | 57 degrees |
Design & Ergonomics(1) | ||
Handle Type | Rear Handle | Top Handle |
Products in the top-left offer the best value (high score, low price).
Professional reviewers praise the Makita XSR01Z as a 'cordless not a worm drive' that operates like one, highlighting its exceptional power, speed, and runtime derived from dual 18V batteries. The brushless motor is noted for eliminating brushes for efficiency, while the electronic brain's ability to sense load and adjust torque/RPM is deemed a 'helluva' performer. It is widely considered the most powerful battery-operated saw available, excelling in deep cuts and cross-cut counts.
Everyday users and aggregated retail feedback highlight smooth, accurate wood cuts and cordless convenience that rivals corded tools. Common praise focuses on the saw's power for heavy framing and long runtime when using 5.0Ah batteries. Recurring complaints center on the 12.4 lb weight feeling bulky for prolonged use and the hassle of needing two batteries.
Professional reviewers and editors consistently praise the DCS590B as DEWALT's top 20V circular saw for professionals, highlighting its ability to match corded saw depth and speed. Hands-on tests confirm its reliability in framing and sheet goods applications, with specific validation of its 1,700 MWO and 5,500 RPM claims.
While direct consumer quotes are limited in the source data, product pages imply strong satisfaction through high-performance claims and kit inclusions. Common praise centers on the tool's runtime and power for 2x material cutting. The primary potential dissatisfaction stems from the tool-only packaging, which may frustrate users who need to purchase batteries separately.
