Napoleon PRO605CSS
Score: 78/100
Kamado Joe Classic Joe Series II 18-inch
Score: 76/100Rankings
The Napoleon PRO605CSS is a premium freestanding charcoal grill offering a massive 605 sq in primary cooking area and a built-in rotisserie for restaurant-quality results. Its substantial 236 lb weight and lack of adjustable cooking grids make it less portable and flexible. Ideal for serious grill enthusiasts hosting large gatherings.
The Kamado Joe Classic Joe II is an 18-inch premium ceramic kamado grill offering excellent heat retention, multi-zone cooking, and a built-in thermometer. Its drawbacks are the very high weight and large footprint, which limit portability. Ideal for experienced grillers with a dedicated outdoor area who value performance over convenience.
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
4.2 sqftbest | 1.74 sqft | |
5.87 sqftbest | 4.58 sqft | |
— | 18 inbest | |
| ↓ lower better | 236 lb | 232 lbbest |
15 yearsbest | 5 years | |
67.5 inbest | 36 in | |
24.75 inbest | 18.11 in | |
37 burgersbest | — |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
Performance(2) | ||
Cooking Area (sqft) | 4.20 sqft | 1.74 sqft |
Total Cooking Area (sqft) | 5.87 sqft | 4.58 sqft |
Dimensions(2) | ||
Height (in) | 67.5 in | 36 in |
Width (in) | 24.75 in | 18.11 in |
Build & Design(5) | ||
Weight (lb) | 236 lb | 232 lb |
Warranty (years) | 15 years | 5 years |
Bowl Material | stainless steel | ceramic |
Lid Material | stainless steel | ceramic |
Construction Material | stainless steel | ceramic |
Products in the top-left offer the best value (high score, low price).
Professional reviewers highlight the PRO605CSS as a high-performance charcoal grill that blends traditional grilling with premium features such as a rotisserie burner, front-loading charcoal door, and precise temperature control, positioning it as a top contender for serious grillers seeking durability and versatility.
Everyday users consistently praise the grill's solid construction, large cooking surface, and convenient mid-cook charcoal access, while the dominant complaints revolve around its substantial weight and the lack of adjustable cooking grids.
“quality product”
“perfect grill”
Professional reviewers highlight the Kamado Joe KJ23RHC for its engineering innovations-especially the Divide & Conquer multi-zone system, the rain-proof Kontrol Tower vent, and the Air Lift hinge-that deliver precise temperature control and ease of use.
Everyday users commonly commend the grill's heat retention, versatile temperature range, and convenient features such as the slide-out ash drawer and built-in thermometer. Recurring themes of criticism focus on the unit's heavy weight, large footprint, and the effort required for initial assembly.
