NewAir Silver Countertop Ice Maker
Score: 76/100
Frigidaire EFIC452
Score: 79/100Rankings
The Frigidaire EFIC452-SSRED XL Maker is a countertop unit delivering up to 40 lb of clear square ice per day with fast cycles and quiet operation. Its need for regular water refills and sizable footprint are the main compromises. Best for frequent ice users such as home bars or outdoor workers who value output over hands-free water supply.
The NewAir ClearIce40 is a countertop ice maker delivering crystal-clear cubes and a high 40 lb daily output in fast 7-minute cycles. Its small storage bin, lack of self-cleaning and timer, and occasional noise limit convenience. Best for home bartenders and small-party hosts who value clear ice over large on-board storage.
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
18.14 kg/daybest | 18.1 kg/day | |
| ↓ lower better | — | 37.5 secondsbest |
35.26 cm | 38.1 cmbest | |
36.2 cmbest | 27.9 cm | |
28.96 cm | 35.6 cmbest | |
1.2 Lbest | — | |
| ↓ lower better | 0 kgbest | — |
— | 2.18 Lbest |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
Performance(1) | ||
Ice Production Capacity (kg/day) | 18.14 kg/day | 18.1 kg/day |
Controls(1) | ||
Control Panel Type | On/off switch | LED |
Features(1) | ||
Ice Type | Cube | Square |
Design & Dimensions(5) | ||
Height (cm) | 35.26 cm | 38.1 cm |
Width (cm) | 36.20 cm | 27.9 cm |
Depth (cm) | 28.96 cm | 35.6 cm |
Installation Type | Freestanding | Countertop |
Material | Stainless steel | Stainless Steel |
Products in the top-left offer the best value (high score, low price).
Professional reviewers and editors consistently commend the ClearIce40 for its high-quality crystal-clear ice, rapid 7-minute production cycles, and insulated design that keeps ice solid longer. They view it as a dependable countertop solution for home bars, emphasizing its BPA-free construction and ease of use, while noting the lack of self-cleaning, timer, and reversible door as notable omissions.
Everyday users praise the clear ice quality, quick cycle times, and compact footprint that fits small spaces. Recurring themes include frustration with the small 2-2.4 lb basket that fills rapidly, the need for manual draining and cleaning, and occasional operational noise.
“no way it holds 39.7 pounds of daily output at once”
“I'm in love”
“fills a chest freezer in days”
Professional demos praise the EFIC452-SSRED for its rapid 24-cube, sub-15-minute cycle, high 40-lb daily output, and quiet, energy-efficient compressor.
Everyday users consistently highlight the plentiful, fast-producing clear ice that eliminates frequent store trips, while also valuing the quiet operation.
