Porter-Cable PCE345
Score: 75/100
BLACK+DECKER BDCJS20B
Score: 72/100Rankings
The Porter-Cable PCE345 is a 6-amp corded orbital jig saw designed for versatile cutting in wood, plastic, metal, and composites, featuring a 7-position speed dial and 4 orbital settings. Its main trade-off is the lack of portability due to the cord and shorter stroke length which can cause blade wandering on intricate curves. It is best suited for DIYers and budget-conscious pros needing a reliable corded saw for straight or curved cuts in workshops.
The BLACK+DECKER BDCJS20B is a lightweight, budget-friendly cordless jigsaw ideal for DIY homeowners and hobbyists. It features a variable-speed trigger and tool-free blade changes, though its brushed motor and limited stroke length restrict heavy-duty performance. It is best suited for precise, detailed cuts in wood and metal for home projects.
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
3,200 SPMbest | 2,500 SPM | |
20.6 mmbest | 19.05 mm | |
120 Vbest | 20 V | |
| ↓ lower better | 2.72 kg | 2.13 kgbest |
45 degreesbest | 45 degreesbest | |
4 positionsbest | — | |
3 yearsbest | 2 years | |
1.83 mbest | — |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
Performance(2) | ||
Max Speed (SPM) (SPM) | 3200 SPM | 2500 SPM |
Stroke Length (mm) | 20.6 mm | 19.05 mm |
Features(2) | ||
Dust Extraction System | false | true |
Blade Change System | Tool-less | Tool-free |
Ergonomics & Build(1) | ||
Tool Weight (kg) | 2.72 kg | 2.13 kg |
Support & Reliability(1) | ||
Warranty Period (years) | 3 years | 2 years |
Power & Battery(3) | ||
Voltage (V) | 120 V | 20 V |
Power Source | Corded | Cordless |
Motor Type | Standard | Brushed |
Professional reviewers and editors describe the Porter-Cable PCE345 as a 'workhorse for the price' that delivers professional results through its robust 6A motor and versatile orbital settings. While it is praised for its value, speed control, and warranty, experts note that it lacks the premium vibration dampening found in higher-end brands like Bosch or DeWalt.
Everyday consumers generally rate the product highly for its power and value, frequently praising its ability to cut through thick wood and its comfortable grip. However, recurring complaints focus on the short cord length, dust accumulation in the speed dial, and difficulty with intricate curves where the blade wanders.
Professional reviewers praise the power relative to its budget price point and versatility for detailed precision work, but note the brushed motor and limited stroke length as drawbacks for heavy-duty applications.
Everyday consumers appreciate the value for casual projects and ease of blade changes, but complain about limitations with thicker materials and short battery life in heavy use.
“Blasts through 2x4s at max orbital”
“Wanders on scrolls”
“It's powerful... use quality blades, take your time, you're going to be able to make a cut”
