Ryobi P505
Score: 74/100
Craftsman CMES510
Score: 78/100Rankings
The Craftsman CMES510 is a robust 15-amp corded circular saw designed for aggressive cutting in wood, featuring a durable magnesium shoe and high no-load speed. It lacks modern safety and convenience features like an electric brake or dust collection, which may deter some professionals. It is best suited for DIYers and homeowners needing a budget-friendly, powerful tool for framing and general jobsite work.
The Ryobi P505 is a compact, 18V ONE+ cordless 5-1/2-inch circular saw designed for DIY homeowners and light trade users. It features a carbide-tipped thin kerf blade capable of cutting through 2x lumber in a single pass at a depth of 1-9/16 inches. It is best suited for users needing portability and ecosystem compatibility for weekend projects.
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
5.5 inches | 7.25 inchesbest | |
1.563 inches | 2.5 inchesbest | |
4,700 RPM | 5,500 RPMbest | |
50 degrees | 55 degreesbest | |
18 V | 120 Vbest | |
| ↓ lower better | 5.3 lbsbest | 11.05 lbs |
— | 15 Abest | |
0.375 inchesbest | — |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
Power & Motor(4) | ||
Power Source | Cordless | Corded |
Voltage (V) | 18 V | 120 V |
Amperage (A) | null A | 15 A |
Motor Type | Brushless | Brushed |
Performance & Cutting(5) | ||
Blade Diameter (inches) | 5.5 inches | 7.25 inches |
Cutting Depth at 90 Degrees (inches) | 1.5625 inches | 2.5 inches |
No-Load Speed (RPM) | 4700 RPM | 5500 RPM |
Bevel Capacity (degrees) | 50 degrees | 55 degrees |
Arbor Size (inches) | 0.375 inches | inches |
Design & Ergonomics(3) | ||
Weight (lbs) | 5.3 lbs | 11.05 lbs |
Cord Length (ft) | null ft | 8 ft |
Handle Type | Rubberized | Contoured over-molded |
Products in the top-left offer the best value (high score, low price).
Professional reviewers praise the Ryobi P505 for its budget-friendly portability and reliability in light-to-medium DIY tasks. The 4,600-4,700 RPM motor is noted for delivering fast, clean cuts through 2x lumber, rivaling many corded tools. Reviewers recommend the P505 or similar older models to save money over newer variants like the PCL500B, as performance differences are negligible.
Everyday consumers appreciate the Ryobi P505 for its ease of use in home repairs, workshops, and tear-down builds. Users frequently praise the compact 5-1/2 inch blade for its maneuverability in tight spaces and the smooth operation of bevel cuts up to 50 degrees. The seamless integration with the Ryobi 18V battery system is a major highlight.
Professional reviewers highlight the CMES510's high-performance 15-amp motor and 5,500 RPM speed as key strengths, while noting the absence of a motor brake and laser guide as omissions compared to premium alternatives.
Everyday users praise the saw's power and ability to cut through various woods without binding, with the comfortable grip frequently mentioned as a positive factor for control.
“Compact and lightweight for easy handling in tight spaces”
“Sufficient power for most DIY wood-cutting tasks, comparable to corded saws”
“Spindle lock position (front-side) less ideal for some users”
