Schlage Plymouth
Score: 88/100
Kwikset SmartCode 917 Satin Nickel
Score: 80/100Rankings
The Schlage FE575 PLY 626 ELA is an electronic keypad lever lock featuring ANSI/BHMA Grade 2 security and an auto-lock function. It offers a 3-year battery life and universal door handing, making it versatile for various installations. It is best suited for multi-family residential properties or light commercial applications needing shared access codes.
The Kwikset SmartCode 917 is a residential electronic lever lock designed for keyless entry with exceptional battery life and Grade 2 security. It lacks smart home integration and remote access, which is a trade-off for users seeking app-based control. It is best suited for homeowners who want keyless entry without smart-home headaches or app dependency.
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
36 monthsbest | 36 monthsbest | |
3 yearsbest | — | |
1.75 inchesbest | 1.75 inchesbest | |
2.75 inchesbest | 2.75 inchesbest | |
150.8 °Fbest | — |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
Power & Battery(1) | ||
Battery Type | 9V | 9V Alkaline |
Support & Warranty(1) | ||
Warranty Length (years) | 3 years | Lifetime (Mechanical/Finish), 1 (Electronics) years |
Security & Access(4) | ||
Security Grade | Grade 2 | Grade 2 / AAA |
Unlock Methods | Keypad, Physical Key | Keypad, Key |
Keypad Type | Illuminated Physical Buttons | Numeric Backlit |
Encryption Standard | SmartKey | |
Installation & Compatibility(3) | ||
Door Thickness Compatibility (inches) | 1.375-1.75 inches | 1.75 inches |
Backset (inches) | 2.375-2.75 inches | 2.375 or 2.75 inches |
Installation Type | Lever Replacement | Lever Deadbolt |
Connectivity & Smart Features(1) | ||
Wi-Fi Standard | None | |
Build & Durability(3) | ||
Material | Metal | |
Operating Temperature (°F) | -31 to 150.8 °F | °F |
Finish | Satin Chrome | Satin Nickel |
Products in the top-left offer the best value (high score, low price).
Professional reviewers consistently highlight the Kwikset SmartCode 917's exceptional battery life and simplicity as its top strengths. The Grade 2/AAA BHMA rating and SmartKey security features are repeatedly cited as making it a secure, residential-grade choice compared to cheaper keypads.
Everyday users generally praise the lock's reliability, aesthetics, and ease of programming, noting that the 9 V battery truly lasts multiple years. The auto-lock mode and SmartKey convenience are frequently appreciated for their practicality in homes and rentals. However, recurring complaints focus on the lack of app connectivity, the restrictive first-4-digit code logic, and the absence of entry logs.
“I wish this connected to Alexa/Google/Home.”
“Great for basic keyless entry; not the right pick if you want full smart-home integration.”
“Very good for users who want keyless entry without smart-home complexity.”
