Seagate Desktop Drive 8TB
Score: 76/100
WD_BLACK P10 Game Drive 5TB
Score: 70/100Rankings
The Seagate Expansion Desktop 8 TB offers huge storage capacity and respectable USB-3.0 speeds, making it ideal for backups and media libraries. Its 5400 RPM drive and modest warranty mean it isn't suited for high-performance or silent-critical environments. Best for home offices and users prioritising capacity over speed.
The WD_BLACK P10 5TB Game Drive provides massive portable storage with solid USB 3.2 Gen 1 performance and wide console/PC compatibility. Its 5400 RPM HDD architecture makes it bulkier and slower than SSD options, and it lacks built-in encryption. Ideal for gamers needing extensive library capacity on the go.
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
8,000 GBbest | 5,000 GB | |
193 MB/sbest | 130 MB/s | |
195 MB/sbest | 130 MB/s | |
| ↓ lower better | 1.102 kg | 0.231 kgbest |
1 years | 3 yearsbest | |
| ↓ lower better | 41 mm | 20.8 mmbest |
256 MBbest | — |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
Storage(1) | ||
Capacity (GB) | 8000 GB | 5000 GB |
Connectivity(2) | ||
Interface | USB 3.0 | USB 3.2 Gen 1 |
USB Version | 3.0 | USB 3.2 Gen 1 |
Warranty & Support(1) | ||
Warranty (years) | 1 years | 3 years |
Compatibility(1) | ||
OS Compatibility | Windows, Mac, Xbox, PS4 | Windows 10+, macOS 11+, PlayStation 4/5, Xbox One/Series X|S, PC |
Performance(2) | ||
Sequential Read Speed (MB/s) | 193 MB/s | 130 MB/s |
Sequential Write Speed (MB/s) | 195 MB/s | 130 MB/s |
Build & Design(3) | ||
Weight (kg) | 1.102 kg | 0.231 kg |
Thickness (mm) | 41 mm | 20.8 mm |
Form Factor | 3.5" | 2.5-inch |
Products in the top-left offer the best value (high score, low price).
Professional reviewers commend the Expansion Desktop 8TB for its solid 170-195 MB/s sequential speeds, generous capacity, and stable flat design, noting it offers excellent value under $200. They also point out the 5400 RPM spindle and mechanical noise as drawbacks, especially for gaming or high-performance scenarios, and mention that its price is comparable to WD alternatives.
Everyday users appreciate the drive's plug-and-play simplicity, fast media transfers, and huge capacity, often expressing confidence that it will last. Common complaints focus on audible noise, the drive filling up quickly for heavy media users, and the slower speed relative to SSDs or gaming-focused HDDs.
Professional reviewers commend the P10 for its massive 5 TB capacity, lightweight chassis, and solid USB 3.2 Gen 1 performance, positioning it as a convenient way to expand console storage without sacrificing portability. However, they also point out its bulkier profile, slower HDD speed versus SSDs, and lack of encryption as notable drawbacks.
Everyday users generally praise the drive's huge capacity and easy plug-and-play compatibility across PlayStation, Xbox and PC, noting its portability and sturdy build. Recurring criticisms focus on its thickness, occasional heat buildup during long sessions, and slower load times compared with SSD alternatives.
