Vaughan Rubber Mallet
Score: 88/100
Estwing MRW20S
Score: 88/100Rankings
The Vaughan RM24 is a 24 oz soft face rubber mallet featuring a forged steel head and dual replaceable rubber tips for versatile striking. Its robust construction and non-marring capabilities make it ideal for woodworking and automotive tasks. It is best suited for professionals and DIYers needing moderate-to-heavy impact without surface damage.
The Estwing Sure Strike 20 oz is a professional-grade hammer designed for framing, roofing, and demolition, featuring a drop-forged solid steel head and a traditional hickory handle. While it offers excellent balance and vibration reduction, the hickory handle requires more maintenance than synthetic alternatives. It is best suited for professional tradespeople who need a durable rip hammer for high-impact work.
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
24 ozbest | 20 oz | |
| ↓ lower better | 24 oz | 20 ozbest |
14 inbest | 13.63 in | |
14 inbest | 13.63 in | |
— | 1.28 inbest |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
Handle & Grip(2) | ||
Handle Length (in) | 14 in | 13.63 in |
Grip Type | Wedge-Lock | Cushion |
Core Specifications(4) | ||
Hammer Type | Soft Face Mallet | Rip Claw |
Head Weight (oz) | 24 oz | 20 oz |
Overall Weight (oz) | 24 oz | 20 oz |
Head Material | High Carbon Steel | Steel |
Head & Face(1) | ||
Face Type | Dual Tip | Smooth |
Features & Build(4) | ||
Overall Length (in) | 14 in | 13.63 in |
Intended Use | Woodworking/Automotive | Framing/Demolition |
Warranty | Manufacturer Warranty | Lifetime |
Finish | Powder-Coated Blue | Silver |
Products in the top-left offer the best value (high score, low price).
Marshalltown editors highlight the 24 oz model as ideal for bigger tasks requiring more power, praising its drop-forged steel head, non-marring options, and versatility.
Search results lack direct consumer reviews or complaints, so no recurring praise or issues from users are documented.
Professional reviewers and editors praise the Estwing Sure Strike hammer for its strength, professional design, and unsurpassed balance. Sources highlight the solid forged steel head and lightweight handles as ideal for tradesmen, with specific recommendations for framers and roofers due to the vibration-reducing grips and ease of use.
Everyday users commonly praise the hammer's balance, comfort, and durability. Recurring themes include ease of use for daily tasks and satisfaction with the quality of materials like hickory. There are no major recurring complaints regarding performance, with users giving full endorsements after months of use.
“perfect, well balanced, with a nice smooth face and quality hickory handle”
“extremely well balanced, easy to use, lightweight”
