Winix A Air Filter
Score: 88/100
Leemone HEPA Replacement Filter
Score: 78/100Rankings
The Winix 115115 is a genuine OEM replacement filter set featuring H13 True HEPA filtration that captures 99.99% of particles down to 0.003 microns. It includes four activated carbon pre-filters for a full year of odor reduction, though the non-washable design and higher upfront cost are notable trade-offs. Best suited for pet owners and allergy sufferers who prioritize maximum filtration efficiency and warranty compliance.
The Leemone AER1 filter set is a cost-effective third-party replacement for Holmes and Bionaire purifiers, featuring H13 True HEPA filtration and carbon booster pre-filters. It offers a direct fit and high efficiency but lacks independent verification of its claims. It is ideal for budget-conscious users needing frequent replacements for pet dander and odor control.
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
12 monthsbest | 12 monthsbest | |
99.99 percentbest | 99.97 percent | |
| ↓ lower better | 0.003 micronsbest | 0.3 microns |
2best | 2best | |
| ↓ lower better | 1.1 lbs | 0.6 lbsbest |
5 | 6best |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | |
|---|---|---|
Compatibility & Fit(1) | ||
Compatible Models | 5300, 5300-2, 5500, 5500-2, 6300, 6300-2, P300, C535, AM90, C909, 9500, 9800 | Holmes HAP240, HAP242, HAP412, HAP422, HAP424, HAP702, HAP706, HAP716, HAP1702, HAP2400, HAP9240-HAP9243, HAP9412; Bionaire aer1-ready |
Physical & Packaging(3) | ||
Weight (lbs) | 1.1 lbs | 0.6 lbs |
Dimensions | 16.6 x 14.1 x 2.2 | 10 x 2 x 10 |
Package Quantity | 5 | 6 |
Filtration Performance(4) | ||
Filtration Efficiency (percent) | 99.99 percent | 99.97 percent |
Minimum Particle Size Captured (microns) | 0.003 microns | 0.3 microns |
Target Contaminants | VOCs, Odors, Particles, Allergens, Smoke | Dust, pet dander, pollen, mold, hair, lint, pets, cooking, smoking |
Pre-Filter Type | Activated Carbon | Carbon Booster |
Products in the top-left offer the best value (high score, low price).
Professional sources emphasize the genuine component advantage, noting that Winix America's official product page highlights engineered optimization for airflow and particle capture. The True HEPA distinction is a key differentiator, with specifications exceeding competitor claims by capturing particles down to 0.003 microns rather than the standard 0.3 microns.
Users consistently report noticeable air quality improvements and appreciate the convenience of a true one-year supply that reduces oversight. Installation is generally described as easy with clear instructions. However, recurring complaints focus on price point shock regarding original pricing, filter availability issues causing frustration during urgent needs, and confusion over model-specific installation requirements for certain units.
Professional coverage of the Leemone AER1 filter is sparse, with no major outlets like Wirecutter or Consumer Reports reviewing it specifically. Claims rely on manufacturer specifications and comparisons to official Holmes filters. One YouTube review of a similar third-party filter (Colorfullife) deemed it a worthwhile upgrade if it matches original Holmes filters, praising fit and initial filtration but noting the need for ongoing comparison.
User feedback is limited in search data, with no aggregated ratings or detailed testimonials provided. Common implied praise from product pages includes effective odor reduction and allergen capture, keeping purifiers at full capacity. A satisfaction guarantee is noted positively by users. Recurring complaints are not explicitly detailed, but potential issues include fit variability or reduced longevity compared to OEM filters due to its third-party nature.
