
Fire-Maple Fixed Star 1
Score: 73/100
Coleman Butane or Propane Camping Stove
Score: 81/100
Rankings

The Coleman Classic 1-Burner stove delivers 7,650 BTU (≈2243 W) with Instastart ignition and a wind baffle, making it reliable for solo cooking. Its limitations include a single burner, short high-heat runtime, and reduced performance in cold weather. Ideal for casual campers and picnickers who need a lightweight, easy-to-use stove.

The Fire-Maple Fixed Star FMS-X1 is a 1 L integrated canister stove system delivering 2200 W and 30% faster boils thanks to heat-exchange fins. Its trade-offs are a heavier package, higher fuel use, and a non-regulated burner that can be slower on low heat. Best for budget-conscious solo or duo hikers who value compactness and speed over ultralight weight.
| Attribute | ![]() | ![]() |
|---|---|---|
| ↓ lower better | 511 g | 249 gbest |
1best | 1best | |
2,200 W | 2,243 Wbest | |
3 yrbest | 3 yrbest | |
30 %best | — |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | ![]() | ![]() |
|---|---|---|
Build & Design(1) | ||
Weight (g) | 511 g | 249 g |
Controls(1) | ||
Ignition Type | Piezo | Instastart |
Power(1) | ||
Power Output (W) | 2200 W | 2243 W |
General(1) | ||
Fuel Type | Canister | Butane/Propane |
Accessories(1) | ||
Included Accessories | Stove, canister stand, lid, cup, mesh bag | Carrying case, Removable porcelain‑coated grate |



Professional reviewers commend the FMS-X1 for its all-in-one packaging, durable construction and the 30% efficiency gain from its heat-exchange fins, noting its strong 2200 W output and suitability for beginners. However, they also flag the non-regulated burner's slower 1 L boil times, the relatively heavy weight, and limited fuel canister capacity as drawbacks, especially for cold-weather or ultra-light applications.
Everyday users praise the compact nesting system, reliable piezo start and solid build, describing it as a great value for budget backpacking and everyday cooking. Recurring complaints focus on higher fuel consumption in wind or cold, occasional igniter failures, and the weight being a concern for ultralight hikers.

Professional reviewers emphasize the stove's strong portability, reliable Instastart ignition, solid wind protection, and sufficient 7,650 BTU output, positioning it as a dependable choice for casual outdoor cooking where weight and ease of use are priorities.
Everyday users overwhelmingly praise the stove for its lightweight build, easy fuel availability, long-term durability, and effective heating, with few complaints and a general sentiment that it performs well for quick, single-pan meals.
“extremely satisfied at a fraction of competition price.”

“will last years”

“Lightweight and compact design with a 5.15-lb weight and carry case for easy transport on camping trips.”


