
⚡ Quick Answer
If you assumed the lowest‑priced grill would earn the lowest praise, the data flips that expectation. The Weber Jumbo Joe 18‑inch, listed at $89.99, has a 4.8‑star rating from 5,553 reviewers—exactly the same rating the $279.00 Q1200 receives from 8,084 fans. Both models sit at opposite ends of the price spectrum, yet they share the highest user satisfaction in our six‑product comparison. That makes the budget‑friendly Jumbo Joe an intriguing contender for anyone watching their wallet.
To keep things organized, we’ve grouped the six grills into three price tiers. The budget tier holds the Jumbo Joe and the Original Kettle 18‑inch Black ($129.00). Mid‑range options are the Original Kettle 22‑inch Black at $149.00 and the Premium Kettle 22‑inch Copper for $249.00. The premium tier features the portable Q1200 and the Master‑Touch 22‑inch, priced at $279.00 and $289.00 respectively. Each tier delivers a different blend of portability, cooking area, and construction, so you can match a grill to your space and cooking style. In the sections that follow we’ll break down how these specs translate into everyday grilling experiences.

Weber Q1200
Its 20.5‑in length packs the Q1200’s high‑rating performance into a compact footprint, making storage easy while still delivering Weber’s trusted grilling quality.

Weber Jumbo Joe 18-inch
Perfect for budget‑conscious grillers, the Jumbo Joe 18‑inch retails at $89.99—about $189 cheaper than the Best Overall while keeping solid Weber reliability.

Weber Original Kettle 22-inch Black
The Original Kettle 22‑inch Black offers a taller 38.5‑in profile and 25‑in cooking area, giving more grill space without the higher price of the Q1200.
Score Analysis
Key score advantages vs. runner-up (Weber Jumbo Joe)
Price Range

Weber Q1200
$279.00

Weber Jumbo Joe 18-inch
$89.99

Weber Original Kettle 22-inch Black
$149.00

Weber Original Kettle Premium 22-inch Copper
$249.00

Weber Master-Touch 22-inch
$289.00

Weber Original Kettle 18-inch Black
$129.00
Spec Comparison
TL;DR: The Weber Q1200 delivers 8,500 BTU of heat in a compact orange tabletop grill that weighs 29.1 lb, folds two side tables for easy transport, and scores 4.8 / 5 from over 8 000 reviewers.
The standout spec is the 8,500 BTU single burner, which reviewers say provides “ample heat for quick” cooking despite the grill’s modest size. At 24.6 in tall, 20.5 in deep and 40.9 in wide, the Q1200 packs a surprisingly wide cooking surface while staying under 30 lb, making it easy to slip into a car trunk or backpack.
Compared with the other five grills in this roundup, the Q1200 sits in the middle of the weight range: it’s heavier than the Jumbo Joe 18‑inch (17.46 lb) and the two kettle models that tip the scales at about 3.31 lb each, but lighter than the Master‑Touch 22‑inch (37.25 lb) and the Original Kettle Premium 22‑inch Copper (32.3 lb). Its width of 40.9 in exceeds the Master‑Touch’s 24 in and the Premium’s 22.5 in, giving a broader footprint while its height and length are shorter than those larger models.
User sentiment highlights the grill’s portability and reliable electronic push‑button ignition, which professional reviewers praise for “quick start without manual lighting.” Users frequently mention the built‑in lid thermometer as a helpful way to monitor temperature on the go. Users note the single‑burner design limits cooking capacity for larger groups, and they need a disposable propane cylinder or an adapter for a full‑size tank.
Pros
Cons
Best for: Buyers willing to invest in a proven, high-quality option
Avoid if: You're on a tight budget or only need basic functionality
TL;DR: The Weber Jumbo Joe 18‑inch portable charcoal grill offers a 240 sq in cooking area, solid porcelain‑enameled construction, and a sturdy Tuck‑N‑Carry lid lock for just $89.99.
With 240 sq in of heat‑retaining cooking space and an 18.5 in grill diameter, the Jumbo Joe packs a surprisingly large surface into a compact 19.75 in tall, 20.5 in wide frame that weighs 17.46 lb.
At $89.99 it sits at the low‑end of the price range, making it cheaper than the other five grills in this roundup. It's considerably heavier than the 3.31‑lb Original Kettle 18‑inch models, yet lighter than the larger Premium 22‑inch Copper (32.3 lb) and the gas‑fuelled Q1200 (29.1 lb) and Master‑Touch (37.25 lb) units.
Reviewers love its “perfect size” for tailgating, camping and beach outings, praising the rust‑resistant aluminum ash catcher, the porcelain‑enameled bowl and lid that resist corrosion, and the One‑Touch cleaning system that speeds ash removal. The Tuck‑N‑Carry lid lock doubles as a handy lid holder, and users frequently highlight this detail in comments. Reviewers note the limited 240 sq in surface for big parties, and the grill’s weight can make it a bit cumbersome compared with the lighter kettle models.
The grill comes with a ten‑year limited warranty on the bowl and lid, five‑year coverage on the One‑Touch system and plastic parts, and two‑year coverage on other components, underscoring Weber’s confidence in durability.
Pros
Cons
Best for: Budget‑friendly grillers who need a portable, sturdy charcoal grill for tailgating, camping or small‑group meals.
Avoid if: You regularly host large parties, prefer gas or electric grilling, or need a lightweight model for frequent backpacking.
“Perfect Size”
TL;DR: The Weber Original Kettle 22‑inch Black offers a sturdy porcelain‑enameled build, 13‑burger capacity, and a lightweight 3.31 lb design for $149, backed by a 4.7‑star rating from over 10 k reviewers.
The standout specification is its 22‑inch cooking diameter, which the manufacturer says can handle up to 13 burgers at once. At 38.5 in tall and 20.5 in wide, the grill provides a generous cooking footprint while staying under 3.31 lb, making it easy to move around a patio or backyard.
Compared with the other five grills in this roundup, the 22‑inch Kettle is lighter than the Premium 22‑inch Copper (32.3 lb) and the Master‑Touch 22‑inch (37.25 lb), but shares the same weight as the 18‑inch Original Kettle (3.31 lb). It is taller than the 18‑inch Original Kettle’s 23 in height and the Jumbo Joe’s 19.75 in, yet shorter than the Master‑Touch’s 29.5 in. Its 20.5 in width is narrower than the Premium’s 22.5 in and the Q1200’s 40.9 in, giving it a more compact footprint than those larger‑area models.
User reviews consistently praise the porcelain‑enameled lid and bowl for resisting rust, scratches, and high heat, and they love the One‑Touch cleaning system that makes ash removal quick. Reviewers also note that the grill’s solid construction lives up to Weber’s reputation for durability, while the 13‑burger capacity is a frequent highlight for family gatherings.
Weber backs the kettle with a 10‑year rust‑through and burn‑through protection warranty on the bowl and lid, plus a 5‑year warranty on the One‑Touch cleaning system, giving owners long‑term confidence in the grill’s resilience.
Pros
Cons
Best for: Most users looking for a well‑reviewed, reliable mainstream option
Avoid if: You have limited desk space or need portability
TL;DR: The Weber Master‑Touch 22‑inch charcoal grill costs $289, delivers 363 sq in of cooking space, and packs a heavy‑gauge porcelain‑enameled bowl for durable, rust‑resistant backyard grilling.
The standout feature is its heavy‑gauge porcelain‑enameled bowl and lid, which professional reviewers cite as exceptionally corrosion‑resistant. Combined with the Gourmet BBQ System hinged grates, you can swap in a wok or griddle mid‑cook, and the One‑Touch ash cleanup lets you pull out the removable aluminized‑steel ash catcher in seconds. At 37.25 lb, the grill also offers a generous 363 sq in cooking area plus an 80 sq in warming rack.
Compared with the other five grills in this roundup, the Master‑Touch is the heaviest—its 37.25 lb weight tops the Q1200’s 29.1 lb and the Original Kettle Premium’s 32.3 lb. It’s also the longest at 42 in, exceeding the Q1200’s 20.5 in length and the Jumbo Joe’s 19.75 in length. While its $289 price sits above the Q1200 and the Original Kettle models, the larger cooking surface and premium construction give it a distinct advantage for serious backyard chefs.
Consumer sentiment notes the grill’s durability and the convenience of the ash‑catcher system, but many users point out that no protective cover comes with it and the 37.25‑lb mass makes moving it around a patio difficult. Reviewers who prioritize portability highlight the weight trade‑off.
Additional technical touches include three adjustable aluminum dampers for precise airflow, a tuck‑away lid holder that keeps the lid out of the way when not in use, and a limited warranty that covers the bowl and lid for ten years against rust‑through. These details round out a grill designed for long‑term outdoor use.
Pros
Cons
Best for: Buyers willing to invest in a proven, high-quality option
Avoid if: Reliability and user satisfaction are your top concerns
TL;DR: The Weber Original Kettle 18‑inch Black gives you classic charcoal grilling in a compact 3.31‑lb frame for $129, making it a solid entry‑level choice for solo cooks or small families.
Weighing just 3.31 lb, this kettle is exceptionally portable, and its closed‑lid footprint—23 in high, 18.5 in long and 23 in wide—fits comfortably on a balcony or small patio. The porcelain‑enameled bowl and lid lock in heat and stand up to rust, peeling and scratching, while a rust‑resistant aluminum damper helps you fine‑tune airflow.
Compared with the 22‑inch Black model, the 18‑inch version measures noticeably shorter (23 in vs 38.5 in) and narrower (18.5 in vs 25 in), yet it weighs about 3.31 lb, similar to the larger model. It’s dramatically lighter than the Jumbo Joe 18‑inch, which tips the scales at 17.46 lb, and far lighter than the Premium 22‑inch Copper at 32.3 lb, so you’ll find it easy to move around.
Users love the One‑Touch cleaning system with its aluminum ash catcher, calling it a major convenience for quick cleanup. Reviewers also highlight the durable porcelain‑enameled surfaces that keep the grill looking new. The main drawback is the limited cooking surface, which many say restricts larger gatherings, and the base model’s lack of a hinged charcoal grate draws occasional criticism.
Pros
Cons
Best for: Budget‑conscious buyers seeking a reliable entry‑level option
Avoid if: You regularly host large parties or need a bigger cooking area
Breakdown

Weber Q1200
Pros

Weber Jumbo Joe 18-inch
Pros

Weber Original Kettle 22-inch Black
Pros

Weber Original Kettle Premium 22-inch Copper
Pros
Cons
Based on scoring data and product specs
Personalized picks

Best Overall Pick
Weber Q1200
Best OverallBest for: Buyers willing to invest in a proven, high-quality option

Weber Jumbo Joe 18-inch
Best for: Budget-conscious buyers seeking a reliable entry-level option
$89.99-$189.01 vs winner
Skip Weber Original Kettle 18-inch Black if…
You have limited desk space or need portability
The Weber Q1200 takes the top spot thanks to its solid 4.8‑star rating from 8,084 reviewers, a generous 8,500 BTU output, and convenient features like an electronic push‑button ignition, pull‑out grease pan and two folding work tables—all for $279.00.
The runner‑up, the Weber Jumbo Joe 18‑inch, shines when you need a portable, budget‑friendly grill for a balcony or tailgate. It offers 240 sq in of cooking space, a compact 18.5‑in grill diameter, and a lightweight 17.46 lb build, all at $89.99.
Pick the Weber Q1200 today and you'll enjoy reliable grilling performance right out of the box.
The Weber Q1200 packs the most amenities, including an electronic push‑button ignition, a built‑in lid thermometer, a pull‑out grease pan, and two folding work tables, all on a compact 24.6‑inch‑high frame. It also delivers 8,500 BTU of heat and is priced at $279, making it a feature‑rich choice for small patios.
No reviews yet — be the first to share your experience.
Please sign in to leave a review
Also considered
$89.99