Rankings
The Netgear GS308E is an entry-level managed 8-port Gigabit switch that combines fanless silent operation with essential features like VLAN and QoS. Its main trade-offs are the absence of PoE and higher-speed uplinks. It is best suited for small office/home office environments that need basic management without PoE.
The Zyxel GS1900-48 is a 48-port gigabit smart-managed rackmount switch notable for its high 100 Gbps switching capacity and fanless silent design. It lacks PoE and detailed reliability specifications, which may limit use in power-hungry or mission-critical environments. Best suited for SMBs needing managed Layer-2 features without PoE.
The TP-Link TL-SG1024DE is a 24-port Gigabit Easy Smart Managed switch delivering 48 Gbps switching capacity, fanless silent operation and a solid set of VLAN, QoS and IGMP features. It lacks PoE and more advanced management capabilities, which may be a drawback for larger or more complex networks. It is best suited for SMBs and home labs that need basic managed features in a compact 1U rack-mount form factor.
The MikroTik CRS328-24P-4S+RM is a 1U rackmount switch delivering 24 PoE-enabled Gigabit ports and four 10 Gbps SFP+ uplinks, ideal for dense power-over-Ethernet deployments. Its drawbacks include the lack of a fanless design and higher power consumption under full PoE load. Best suited for enterprises and SMBs that need extensive PoE and flexible OS options.
The TP-Link TL-SG1024S is a 24-port unmanaged Gigabit Ethernet switch delivering a non-blocking 48 Gbps switching capacity and fanless silent operation. It lacks advanced features such as VLAN, QoS, and PoE, and power draw can reach up to 20 W under load. Ideal for small-to-medium networks that prioritize simple high-speed connectivity.
The Cudy GS1024L is a 24-port fanless gigabit switch with strong non-blocking performance and basic VLAN/Extend features. It sacrifices PoE, advanced management and fiber uplinks to keep cost and noise low. Ideal for quiet small-office or home-lab environments that need many gigabit ports without power delivery.
The Tenda TEG1016D is a 16-port unmanaged Gigabit switch offering high switching capacity and robust surge protection in a silent fanless metal chassis. Its trade-offs are the lack of PoE and advanced management features. Best suited for SMEs or surveillance setups that need simple, reliable connectivity.
The USW-16-POE is a 1U rack-mount managed switch offering 36 Gbps switching, a touchscreen, and dual SFP uplinks. Its PoE budget of 42 W and limited PoE+ ports can constrain larger PoE deployments. Best suited for small-office rack environments needing quiet, managed PoE with fiber flexibility.
The MikroTik CRS309-1G-8S+IN is a compact, fanless 9-port switch delivering 162 Gbps switching capacity and dual-boot RouterOS/SwOS. Its limited management port options and lack of 10 GbE RJ45 uplinks may restrict some deployments. Ideal for space-constrained environments needing dense 10 GbE SFP+ connectivity.
The TRENDnet TEG-S3160 is a 16-port unmanaged 2.5 GbE switch delivering 80 Gbps aggregate bandwidth and a silent fanless design with flexible rack or wall mounting. It offers plug-and-play simplicity but lacks VLAN support and can exhibit occasional reboot-related connectivity glitches. It fits small-business or home-office environments needing many 2.5 Gbps ports without advanced features.
| Attribute | | | | | | | | | | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
48 Gbps | 128 Gbps | 48 Gbps | 36 Gbps | 80 Gbps | 32 Gbps | 16 Gbps | 48 Gbps | 100 Gbps | 162 Gbpsbest | |
35.7 Mpps | 95.2 Mppsbest | 35.712 Mpps | 27 Mpps | 59.52 Mpps | 1.488 Mpps | — | 35.7 Mpps | 74 Mpps | — | |
24 | 28 | 24 | 16 | 16 | 16 | 8 | 24 | 48best | 9 | |
1 Gbps | 1 Gbps | 1 Gbps | 1 Gbps | 2.5 Gbps | 1 Gbps | 1 Gbps | 1 Gbps | 1 Gbps | 10 Gbpsbest | |
— | 450 Wbest | — | 42 W | — | — | — | — | — | — | |
| ↓ lower better | 13.85 W | 44 W | 15 W | 60 W | — | 12 W | 3.7 Wbest | — | — | 23 W |
— | — | — | — | — | — | 64best | — | — | — | |
| ↓ lower better | 1.7 kg | 4.54 kg | 1.057 kg | 2.8 kg | 0.98 kg | — | 0.5 kgbest | 1.56 kg | 3.965 kg | 0.5 kgbest |
Click an attribute name to sort · Green = best, red = worst (relative to this comparison)
| Attribute | | | | | | | | | | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Performance(2) | ||||||||||
Switching Capacity (Gbps) | 48 Gbps | 128 Gbps | 48 Gbps | 36 Gbps | 80 Gbps | 32 Gbps | 16 Gbps | 48 Gbps | 100 Gbps | 162 Gbps |
Forwarding Rate (Mpps) | 35.7 Mpps | 95.2 Mpps | 35.712 Mpps | 27 Mpps | 59.52 Mpps | 1.488 Mpps | — | 35.7 Mpps | 74 Mpps | — |
Ports(2) | ||||||||||
Number of Ports | 24 | 28 | 24 | 16 | 16 | 16 | 8 | 24 | 48 | 9 |
Port Speed (Gbps) | 1 Gbps | 1 Gbps | 1 Gbps | 1 Gbps | 2.5 Gbps | 1 Gbps | 1 Gbps | 1 Gbps | 1 Gbps | 10 Gbps |
Power(2) | ||||||||||
PoE Power Budget (W) | — | 450 W | — | 42 W | — | — | — | — | — | — |
Maximum Power Consumption (W) | 13.85 W | 44 W | 15 W | 60 W | — | 12 W | 3.7 W | 13.1-20.2 W | — | 23 W |
Network(1) | ||||||||||
VLAN Support | true | true | true | true | false | — | 64 | — | true | — |
Design(3) | ||||||||||
Mounting Options | Rack-mount (1U) | Rack mount 1U | Desktop, Rackmount | Rack mount 1U | Rack-mountable; Wall-mountable | Desktop/rack-mount | Desktop, Wall, Rack | Desktop or 19-inch rackmount (1U) | Rackmount | Rackmount |
Weight (kg) | 1.7 kg | 4.54046 kg | 1.057 kg | 2.8 kg | 0.98 kg | — | 0.5 kg | 1.56 kg | 3.9654 kg | 0.5 kg |
Dimensions (HxWxD) (mm) | 43.18x180.34x294.64 mm mm | 44x443x300 mm | 44x182x270 mm | 1.7 x 17.4 x 7.9 inches mm | Height: 26.9 mm, Width: 127.5 mm, Length: 285.8 mm mm | 254x93x345 mm mm | 158x101x29 mm | 44 x 180 x 294 mm mm | 43.18x203.2x200.66 mm | 28x115x141 mm |
General(2) | ||||||||||
Operating Temperature (°C) | — | -20 to 60 °C | 0-40 °C | -5 to 40 °C | — | — | 0-40 °C | — | — | -40 to 70 °C |
Warranty (years) | Limited Lifetime years | — | 2 years | 1 years | — | 3 years | 5 years | — | 2 years | — |
Reliability(1) | ||||||||||
MTBF (hours) | — | 200000 hours | — | — | — | — | 1600000 hours | — | — | — |
Features(1) | ||||||||||
LED Indicators | — | — | — | — | true | true | false | false | — | — |
Products in the top-left offer the best value (high score, low price).
Professional coverage is limited but highlights the TL-SG1024DE's silent fanless operation, green-technology power savings and solid 48 Gbps switching performance. Reviewers appreciate the easy setup and basic VLAN/QoS capabilities for SMBs, while noting the management suite is modest compared to fully managed switches and the lack of PoE restricts certain deployments.
Everyday users praise the silent operation, straightforward plug-and-play installation and reliable gigabit performance. Common themes include appreciation for the compact rack-mount form factor and energy efficiency, with occasional concerns about heat buildup and the absence of PoE.
“flawless operation after initial setup”
“network drops on restarts”
“ultra fast data transfer speeds”
Professional sources highlight the GS1024's reliable, non-blocking performance, silent fanless design, and the added flexibility of VLAN and Extend DIP switch modes, but note the lack of PoE, management features, and fiber uplinks compared to higher-end models.
While direct user reviews are scarce, typical consumer expectations point to appreciation for easy setup, silent operation, and value, with recurring concerns about the absence of PoE and limited advanced features.
Professional reviewers commend the USW-16-POE for its fanless chassis, integrated touchscreen, and SFP uplinks, noting its suitability for noise-sensitive rack environments.
Pros: Eight PoE+ ports delivering up to 32W per port for powering enterprise devices such as APs, cameras, and phones.; Fanless design provides silent operation, making it suitable for noise-sensitive environments like offices and classrooms.; Integrated 1.3" touchscreen LCM display offers immediate visual status of power, ports, and network health.; Compact 1U rack-mount form factor enables efficient use of limited cabinet space while still providing 16 ports.; Dual 1 Gbps SFP fiber uplink ports allow flexible backbone connectivity and future-proofing with fiber links.
Professional reviewers commend the TEG-S3160 for its solid metal construction, silent fanless operation, and straightforward plug-and-play experience, positioning it as a cost-effective way to add 2.5 G connectivity to small networks. However, they caution that the lack of VLAN support and occasional reboot-related connectivity glitches may limit its suitability for more managed or enterprise environments.
Everyday users generally appreciate the high port count, reliable high-speed performance, and quiet metal design, noting that setup is effortless. Recurring complaints focus on network drops after reboots, VLAN incompatibility, and occasional firmware quirks.
Professional sources are limited, but manufacturer and retailer descriptions highlight the TEG1016D's reliability for surveillance and SME networks, emphasizing its 2000 Mbps duplex speeds, robust 6 kV lightning protection, and fanless silent design as key selling points.
Professional reviewers and editors describe the GS308E as an entry-level managed 8-port Gigabit Ethernet switch aimed at small office and home office environments. It offers a fanless, silent design, non-blocking architecture, and essential managed features such as VLAN and QoS while consuming very low power.
Pros: Extremely low power consumption (3.7W maximum) ideal for always-on deployments.; Silent fanless design eliminates acoustic noise, suitable for noise-sensitive environments.; Compact form factor (158 × 101 × 29 mm) fits space-constrained installations.; Non-blocking switching architecture provides full wire-speed performance for all ports.; Affordable entry-level managed switch with VLAN and QoS support for small networks.; Cons: No Power over Ethernet (PoE) support limits use with PoE devices such as IP cameras or phones.; Lacks 10 Gbps ports, restricting future high-speed connectivity upgrades.; Only 4K MAC address table entries, fewer than some competitors offering 8K.; Modest 192 kB buffer size compared to higher-end models may affect burst traffic handling.; Not stackable, preventing easy expansion of multiple switches into a single logical unit.; VLAN support limited to 64 (or 32 in some regions), which may be insufficient for larger segmented networks.
Professional reviewers and editors praise the TL-SG1024D for its high throughput, non-blocking design, and energy-saving fanless operation, noting that it delivers reliable Gigabit performance with simple plug-and-play setup.
Everyday users appreciate the straightforward installation, silent operation, and consistent Gigabit speeds for home or small office networks, while some express disappointment over the absence of advanced configuration options and occasional concerns about power draw under heavy load.
Professional reviewers and editors commend the GS1900-48 for its strong 100 Gbps switching capacity, intuitive web management, silent fanless design, and power-saving EEE features, while noting the lack of PoE and limited detailed reliability specifications as drawbacks for more demanding deployments.
Everyday users appreciate the reliable Gigabit performance, easy setup, and quiet operation, but some are disappointed by the missing PoE capability and unclear rack-mount dimensions, leading to occasional concerns about installation fit.
Professional reviewers commend the CRS309-1G-8S+IN for its affordability, compact fanless design, and powerful RouterOS feature set, but they caution that the lack of a 10 GbE RJ45 management port and inconsistent dimension data may limit its appeal for certain deployments.
No consumer reviews or forum posts were found in the source data, so everyday user sentiment cannot be determined.
